The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Dang It Moon Moon!]

Would this be fair?

[Rbpuppy]

the joker IS NOT 2 nons, i have no idea where that value came from? only true dates sometimes fetch that much.
grapes have neutral demand and are relatively easy to swap for an sorb/sorb worth pets. rainbow mane seems to be a bit under an non after the rarity change. all in all definitely not a bad trade for the joker

unfortunately, this just isn't true
recent trade data shows the "demand" for the joker has raised over the 1.5 nons of value, leaving it to be warranted around 2
the grapes are actually unimaginably hard to trade off, even for a swap to a sorb

this unfortunately just wasn't a good offer

I’d have to agree with haneli on this. I’ve had multiple trades for my Joker where’s it’s valued at 2 Nons at least. Granted mine is a TD, but when I traded off my non TD Joker away a few months back I got over 2 Nons for it.
Here’s a few examples of recent trades I’ve gotten valuing my joker at 2 Nons:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92457698&userid=42960&signature=NEYseG0V4he7eANtwHzcFQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92596252&userid=42960&signature=PVhHSWcl_URzJvvFH1WXAg

[Crazycarrots3]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92633781&userid=745284&signature=cmBB4kDUam3MYj_TJwQsbQ

Is this fair? I’m really debating on it idkkkkk

[Crazycarrots3]

[quote="Cøpacetic"][quote="Cøpacetic"]Quick opinions please? I dunno what my bat is worth
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92641067&userid=881527&signature=tbHW_34w4RDeKIZC2Q-DvA[/quote][/quote]


I don’t believe this is fair , no

[Crazycarrots3]

[quote="Dang It Moon Moon!"][center][url=https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92642620&userid=797249&signature=DD-mt8eat-5Slu8x0PIJrg]Would this be fair?[/url][/center][/quote]


Not to the person trading all the rares away, the cat is a 2009 rare and they are offering up a 2009 rare aaaas well as other 2010 rares

[dendro]

I need opinions ASAP :3

(Bulk) Which is the better offer? :0

First Trade

Second Trade

Thanks!

[Cøpacetic]

Quick opinions please? I dunno what my bat is worth
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92641067&userid=881527&signature=tbHW_34w4RDeKIZC2Q-DvA

I don’t believe this is fair , no

To who..? And why?

[Crazycarrots3]

[quote="Cøpacetic"][quote="Crazycarrots3"][quote="Cøpacetic"][quote="Cøpacetic"]Quick opinions please? I dunno what my bat is worth
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92641067&userid=881527&signature=tbHW_34w4RDeKIZC2Q-DvA[/quote][/quote]


I don’t believe this is fair , no[/quote]
To who..? And why?[/quote]


To the person with the bat, the dates don’t math and it’s unfair, idk that’s just my opinion

[Space Avian]

To the person with the bat, the dates don’t math and it’s unfair, idk that’s just my opinion

Keep in mind that the pets on the other side are both store pets.
The dog is a low advent, and the deer is an early 2010 rare

I don't know if the bat has any special demand, but it's a 2010 very rare which is worth one '09 rare

[Tapedeck]

Howdy folks, I’ve got another trade needing help
xXxXx


Edit: and this bad boy too please ? Never had a JLT before hehe