The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Andromeda123]

Would this be fair? Take demand into consideration please

Thank you for the person who helped me, second opinions?

[mitsurugi]

first time posting here, was wondering if this is fair?

[☽isa☾]

I'm not good with store pet worths. How fair is this trade, with and without calculating the C$? thanks!

So from what I understand based on this thread your side is worth 1-1.5 non.
Their side has:
Pink Patchy= 1.5-3 MA
Pink Striped= 1.5-3 MA
Palomino Tess= 2-3 MA
UR Purple Tess= .25-.5 non
Set of 4 Griphons= 4-5 '09 Rares each so between 16-25 '09 Rates altogether
Jackalope= MA
08 Advent= MA
Fluffy Brown dog= 5 '09 Rares-MA.
So there side is about 1-2 non, if my math is correct, without the C$.
7-8 '09 Rares are equivalent to 1 MA
10-12 MA are equivalent to 1 non.

Based on this thread I would say the C$ is worth about a Sept list pet... maybe a bit lower.

I'm definitely not an expert so maybe ask another opinion as well. Good luck!

Hi! I wanted to share my own calculations of this, and ask someone for another opinion.

4 gryphons = 2 MA * 4 = 8 MA
Pink patchy + pink striped = 1.5-2 MA * 2 = 3-4 MA
Palomino Tess Horse = 2 MA
UR purple horse = 0.25-0.5 nons (closer to 0.25, so I'll calculate closer to that) = 4 MA
Jackalope = 1 MA
purple star dog = 1 MA
fluffy store dog = 1 MA

the pets add up to 20-21 MA. the ur strawberry usually goes for the higher end of 1-1.5 nons according to past trades, so I value it at 1.5 nons. 10-12 MA = 1 non, so this is definitely overpay.
I calculated really differently myself for the exact worth, so can someone else give an opinion? thank you so much!!

[OriginalStar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92247900&userid=854251&signature=XimzuEBeXTXpyxiYbvoMqA

Fair?

[Panda-Love-100]

is this fair? I’m not very good with item worths...

! trade !

Same for this one too.

! trade !

[LunarLights20]

I'm not too sure about this one, any advice?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92287696&userid=686803&signature=B82xT4kj_WCUjhESM6MjEw

[ahirked]

Hi! I wanted to share my own calculations of this, and ask someone for another opinion.

4 gryphons = 2 MA * 4 = 8 MA
Pink patchy + pink striped = 1.5-2 MA * 2 = 3-4 MA
Palomino Tess Horse = 2 MA
UR purple horse = 0.25-0.5 nons (closer to 0.25, so I'll calculate closer to that) = 4 MA
Jackalope = 1 MA
purple star dog = 1 MA
fluffy store dog = 1 MA

the pets add up to 20-21 MA. the ur strawberry usually goes for the higher end of 1-1.5 nons according to past trades, so I value it at 1.5 nons. 10-12 MA = 1 non, so this is definitely overpay.
I calculated really differently myself for the exact worth, so can someone else give an opinion? thank you so much!!

- gryphons = 2 MA ea. (source)
- pink patchy / striped sept = 1.5-2 MA ea. (source)
- palomino tess = 1.5-2 MA (trade evidence + source)
- purple tess = 0.25-0.5 nons, closer to 0.25 (trade evidence + see this discussion point + source)
- jackalope = 1 MA ea. (source)
- purple star bobtail = 1 MA (trade evidence + source)
- fluffy store dog = 4-5 09 rares to 7-8 09 rares (MA) (source), though from personal experience I wouldn't go below an MA value for this store pet. trade evidence seems to value it from a t5 to a t7 advent <:

anyway you pretty much hit the nail on the head for all the worths, so I agree, this is overpay uvu

is this fair? I’m not very good with item worths...

! trade !

Same for this one too.

! trade !

trade 1-
- lunar earring, chibi wing = current store items, worth 1.2c$ and 3c$ respectively (=4.2c$)
- pearl headpiece = 2012 common/uncommon (=4-9c$)
- feather necklace + stud (x4) = 2019 common/uncommon per set (2 items per set) (=0.5-2c$)
== 10.2-15.2c$

your side:
- backgammon pieces (x30) = users received 15x pieces, so lets say ughhh,,,, god it's a miniscule amount per piece,, maybe a 2019 uncommon for 15x pieces, so 2 2019 uncommons?
- 35c$ == 2009 rare worth
--> extremely unfair to you!

trade 2-
- catching the first snowflake = 2014 common
- glitter x4 = 2015 common/uncommon ea.
- snow globe snow = 2016 vc/c
- golden bracelets = 2020 common

your side:
- smooth pb = 2020 common/uncommon
- animal egg 88 = 2020 unc
- glowy creatures (x2) = 2020 unc ea.
---> unfair to the top, they're overpaying!

[yomibird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92297031&userid=13606&signature=EGmfV2VtplRYNqqDbq0-nQ

Is this fair? I thought the Scarf pps was worth 2 MAs, then I have heard it worth 3 MAs or maybe more.

[Panda-Love-100]

-snip-

Thanks! Could I get help with this trade as well please?

[Smokeyman4ever!]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92297189&userid=994917&signature=_7oux672uvSsEJ09JW-TYg

Need help