The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Andromeda123]

Would this be fair? Take demand into consideration please

[KnownAsAFangirl]

Any ideas on whether this is fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92294771&userid=725458&signature=8mMdl2zD-cGwfcOm-LsW7Q
Thanks

[Flicka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91349598&userid=9355&signature=_1JnM116u2LUp9PkpDbufA Is this ok?

[yomibird]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92297031&userid=13606&signature=EGmfV2VtplRYNqqDbq0-nQ

Is this fair? I thought the Scarf pps was worth 2 MAs, then I have heard it worth 3 MAs or maybe more.

[Horsesrule5000]

Would this be fair? Take demand into consideration please

Their side:
Purple tox (.5 nons)
Total = .5 nons/6 MAs

Your side:
3 2012 store pets (1 MA each)
Boar pps (1 MA)
cream advent (1-1.5 MA)
Total = 5-5.5 MAs
So this would actually be .5-1 MAs unfair to them.

Any ideas on whether this is fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92294771&userid=725458&signature=8mMdl2zD-cGwfcOm-LsW7Q
Thanks

Unfair to them. Your cow is from 2014, and their pps dog is from 2008. So, the pps pup and 1 of the camels alone would be fair to you. The rest is overpay

[chorexdemon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92298302&userid=991346&signature=PMX08t37azCU5bALgvigvg

if anyone could please help that would be so greatly appreciated

[Jojo Bear]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92291383&userid=860974&signature=6w-8D86JlD-wQ6RtYo2v4Q
Thoughts asap please and thank you!

[Deerdancer]

This trade is offering two store pets I need, in exchange for a bunch of old items. Is it fair? Thank you for your time.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92298365&userid=203847&signature=_sSW0hVYZXU6nSmfaclsJw

[OriginalStar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92247900&userid=854251&signature=XimzuEBeXTXpyxiYbvoMqA

Fair?

[ahirked]

This trade is offering two store pets I need, in exchange for a bunch of old items. Is it fair? Thank you for your time.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92298365&userid=203847&signature=_sSW0hVYZXU6nSmfaclsJw

2x 2017 stores = late 09 rare ea., == 2 09 rares

items on your side:
- grey malk fairy = 09 r/vr
- bunny = 2011 uc
- dark, light, earth dragon = 2011 uc/r ea.
- elf set = no set value, recent trading seems to estimate it anywhere from an 09 vr (see discussion point here) to an 09 r+ per piece (see various trades here). a user recently stated that they think a set is worth somewhere from a High Advent to a Low Sept, however I'd use that guesstimation with caution, considering other trades seem to indicate a lower value (e.g. this).

on a **personal level**, I'd value the cloak at 2 09 rares, the dress at 2 09 rares, elf bracers an 09 rare and the rest of the items at 2009 rare ea., which totals this up to about 10 09 rares max (just over an MA).
please do note that this is just my personal evaluation based on what I paid <:
- horse costume set (3x items) = 2011 rare
- fire feet = 2011 uc
- everything else = 2012 c/uc ea.

I'd say one 2017 store would be a good 1:1 swap for the malk fairy (valuing it at an 09 rare), and seeing as 4 2011 rares = 2009 rare, the horse costume + the three 2011 dragons* would be a fair swap for the other dragon. everything else is major overpay on your side!
*depending on whether you value them at an uncommon each, or a rare each.