The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[imhappyboy]

is this fair?

would appreciate any help since i suck with pet values :c

[☽isa☾]

how fair is this trade with demand? thank you so much!!!

[NonbinaryNobody]

We both aren't sure how much the butterfly wolf is worth. Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92244520&userid=1007328&signature=AdMQ_Ag1ADA-mye21Np75g

[skinnedfur]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92243898&userid=847408&signature=2jlm9P04hz5v3v9STdWfDQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92244231&userid=847408&signature=4EtLJ6XPVcI-2GhHf5kNDQ

thoughts on both of these, ty in advance c:

pls :')

[jasparry7]

Can I have an opinion on this please? Thank you in advance! x
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92244807&userid=989316&signature=JS55ojh-SH_HCQwYdkiUhA

[mykola]

is this fair?

would appreciate any help since i suck with pet values :c



i'd call this relatively fair, though it really depends. the one on your side is a staff pet but doesn't go for as much as say, the malk mutant or the shima lt, but it is a staff pet nevertheless and goes for a little more then the average mid 09 rare
they dont really have any super low demand pets on their side, and the 2 '10 rares would add up to your '09 rare. as i stated before, it is a staff pet so the small uncommon and below add pretty much makes up for the gap. i suppose it's a matter of preference really.

i suggest you get a second opinion tho :3

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92243898&userid=847408&signature=2jlm9P04hz5v3v9STdWfDQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92244231&userid=847408&signature=4EtLJ6XPVcI-2GhHf5kNDQ

thoughts on both of these, ty in advance c:


pls :')



for the bottom one, thats not fair. they're offering low demand pets that are rare and uncommon which are from earlier dates (well the uncommon is malk so slightly higher demand) for your 09 vr, which happens to be a nick toxic which goes for a decent amount, so id say it wouldn't be fair. get a second opinion though

We both aren't sure how much the butterfly wolf is worth. Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92244520&userid=1007328&signature=AdMQ_Ag1ADA-mye21Np75g



i wouldn't consider it totally fair because yours is a vr and theirs, while 2 are only rares, one from the same year with much lower demand as a pet, and a low demand species, and the other from the next year with a little less demand, but the same species. as always, get a second opinion :')

[KioloDovahkiin]

any advice on this trade please?

the malk spider is from feb 2012.

[EditPink]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92246087&userid=902320&signature=6HRyPoajpJcW3pv2Pp9_Jg

a bid for my auction?

[Pinky]

Would this be fair? Apparently the cooked meat is worth a lot? and I couldn’t find anything about the cupcake 4
Thanks in advance!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92237065&userid=965062&signature=b9_N2UDf89kZpDwAiA-vBw

[Jojo Bear]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92244742&userid=860974&signature=3liQC-DZXSoQplHMt8rANA
demand wise should I accept?