The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Andromeda123]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92049842&userid=819890&signature=IJqIDVV2Rdd1XetzrSSTVg

Should I do this? Take demand into consideration

[moonviewing]

is this fair? (wwa + t8 september + t7 advent for purple tox)
also, hows this? (wwa + ur malk for clockwork bun)
whoops, more trades- (ur malk for 2700C$)
another trade, (a Lot of things for joker bun)

quote count: 5 (looking for second opinions on first 3!)

[raysn]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92043120&userid=788364&signature=IqOzN85BL_iCPufm4-G_8A

[Assassins]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92026499&userid=744505&signature=M5mbpwA6mPsiMz58Nr_jow
Is this fair?

Been asking for a moment now ^^;

[Kristalli]

Could I get an opinion on this trade, the items don’t need to be counted in the trade they are a freebie add on.

My PMs are also open if somebody prefers to comment that way.
Thank you!

[VNKP]

Got this item trade. I'm not too sure on items so any help would be great!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92036078&userid=985924&signature=RTYbGnMfIm9xG-ttn-egDA

[ahirked]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92049842&userid=819890&signature=IJqIDVV2Rdd1XetzrSSTVg

Should I do this? Take demand into consideration

avocado = 1 non
red android = 0.5 nons

imo androids have more demand than avocados, which can be hard to trade off - but they are overpaying by a whole 0.5 nons. ultimately it's up to you and your partner, and how you value the avocado!

is this fair? (wwa + t8 september + t7 advent for purple tox)
also, hows this? (wwa + ur malk for clockwork bun)
whoops, more trades- (ur malk for 2700C$)
another trade, (a Lot of things for joker bun)

quote count: 5 (looking for second opinions on first 3!)

trade 1:
purple tox = 0.5 nons

your side:
- wood angel = 0.5-1 nons
- tricolour cake dog = 2-3 MAs, but trades more consistently for 2 MAs
- cream advent = 1 MA

personally I'd say you are overpaying! from my experience purple toxics consistently trade for 0.5 nons/sorb worth (x)
---
trade 2:
clockwork bun goes for 1-1.5 nons

- wwa = 0.5-1 nons
- ur malk = 1-1.5 nons

the ur malk on its own should be a decent swap for the clockwork bun, I believe
---
trade 3:
ur malk == 1,500-2,500c$ according to this
I couldn't find any trade data to back this up (as in, ur malk for c$ alone - the vr/omgsr successful trades thread has c$ trades for the ur malk, but as an add-on to pets).

I'd get a third opinion on this one, simply because I am conservative with trading my valuable pets for c$. otherwise I think it's a good offer (:
---
trade 4:
joker bun = 1 non

your side:
- white scarf dog = 3-4 09 rares
- wwa = 0.5-1 nons
- winged blood dog = 2 MAs
- cake dog = 2-3 MAs, but trades more consistently for 2 MAs
- desert swirl pps = 1 MA
- green fronted holly = 2-3 MAs
- elf rat = see here
- cream advent = 1 MA
== 0.5-1 nons, 8-10 MAs (0.75-1 non), ~9-11 09 rares*
=== 1.25-2 nons, 1 MA and 1-3 09 rares
* depending on how you value the rat

personally I think this one is unfair to you, but I'd get a second opinion in case I missed something/totalled it up wrong.

[memento.mori]

hello~
could i have opinions on this trade?
thank you for your help!! <3

LINK

[caffeinate]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92047917&userid=1003859&signature=4HFbjBVHAThkaOvivj1RWg

?

[boston]

hello~
could i have opinions on this trade?
thank you for your help!! <3

LINK

If you value each of your pets around a MA it’s close to fair, slightly unfair to the pineapple. Pineapple can be valued around a non and a non can go for around 10-12. You have around 9 if you value each store pet and the shima at a MA.