The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[skinnedfur]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92024058&userid=1004508&signature=Yha3cRQlxFHSyTtu1fSb8Q
how fair are either of these?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92024755&userid=1004508&signature=X8NdCj6-mOfFZd3hu7k3nw

i also got this one
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92026503&userid=1004508&signature=b9m29agxMyWrIsZjwuhr_g

and another trades/viewtrade.php?id=92026569&userid=1004508&signature=FqThAaqDgWPTNb1ico8wSg[/quote]

and another offer
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92026744&userid=1004508&signature=sL4ix2pKYzLS_QHO9jrqcQ[/quote]

i would appriciate some help if someone is willing to go through all that[/quote]

the first trade is fair, the 2009 is just an added rare as both the toxic and sorb are both a solid .5 non, i'd go with whatever pet you value more !

the rat is valued at .5-1 non (more .5 non), however in this case the sorb would have more value c$ and demand wise

their side only reaches to about 2 MA's, your sorb is worth 5-7 MA's, its unfair to you

the tess horse is valued at .25-.5 nons, though it more regularly fetches .25 as it's demand is pretty low, the ghost cat is only worth 3-4 09 rares, though regularly more as it has a steady demand
unless you value the tess horse at .5 nons its unfair to you

the first trade would be the best option if you are looking to trade your sorb

[skinnedfur]

is this fair for my warrior cat
THIS TOO PLZ IDK old rares
this too plz

[/quote]

warrior cats have very high demand however they arent list pets (to my knowledge), the first trade is a pretty big overpay, you could get more than 1 warrior cats with the pets they are giving

the second trade is also good, spiders have ok demand, not high or low, i would accept it

[ahirked]

is this fair for my warrior cat
THIS TOO PLZ IDK old rares
this too plz

warrior cats have very high demand however they arent list pets (to my knowledge), the first trade is a pretty big overpay, you could get more than 1 warrior cats with the pets they are giving

the second trade is also good, spiders have ok demand, not high or low, i would accept it

I disagree, second trade was very unfair to the spider. bottom side would have had to add a lot more commons and lower for this to be fair.
2010 r = 4 2010 uc = 16 2012 uc = 64 2014 uc = 256 2016 uc = 1024 2018 uc (using this chart)
granted no one would trade 1000 2018 uncommons for a 2010 rare, but it still demonstrates that this trade was unfair to the top.

[Kunilamew]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92024058&userid=1004508&signature=Yha3cRQlxFHSyTtu1fSb8Q
how fair are either of these?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92024755&userid=1004508&signature=X8NdCj6-mOfFZd3hu7k3nw

i also got this one
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92026503&userid=1004508&signature=b9m29agxMyWrIsZjwuhr_g

and another trades/viewtrade.php?id=92026569&userid=1004508&signature=FqThAaqDgWPTNb1ico8wSg

and another offer
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92026744&userid=1004508&signature=sL4ix2pKYzLS_QHO9jrqcQ[/quote]

i would appriciate some help if someone is willing to go through all that[/quote]

the first trade is fair, the 2009 is just an added rare as both the toxic and sorb are both a solid .5 non, i'd go with whatever pet you value more !

the rat is valued at .5-1 non (more .5 non), however in this case the sorb would have more value c$ and demand wise

their side only reaches to about 2 MA's, your sorb is worth 5-7 MA's, its unfair to you

the tess horse is valued at .25-.5 nons, though it more regularly fetches .25 as it's demand is pretty low, the ghost cat is only worth 3-4 09 rares, though regularly more as it has a steady demand
unless you value the tess horse at .5 nons its unfair to you

the first trade would be the best option if you are looking to trade your sorb[/quote]


sorry for quoting you with this, but how's this one (the first link, that doesn't seem to work) trades/viewtrade.php?id=92024058&userid=1004508&signature=Yha3cRQlxFHSyTtu1fSb8Q

[Andromeda123]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92026740&userid=819890&signature=RgwJerz-Nuz-8x5dIFTyiA


Should I take this? Take demand into consideration please

[/nyx.]

Could someone help me with this? My C$ skills need work. [trade]

[skinnedfur]

Have two here, would need help:
nr 1 and nr 2 (I actually like them both, just want to be sure it's not a rip off)

1. ice cat goes for 1-1.5 nons with decent demand
their tess horse is .25-.5 nons (more .25 due to demand)
striped dog goes for 1.5-2 MA's with stable demand
bobtail dog goes for 1 MA with stable demand
blue grinner goes for 2 MA's with stable demand
in total their side is .75 nons if you value the horse at .25nons and 1 non if you value it at .5nons
- in my opinion its underpay -

2. Joker bun goes for 1-1.5 nons, it has good demand but it doesnt really cross over 1.5 nons, BMD bun is about 1 MA
on their side the non-swirl is a solid 1 non, all their other pets and items would add up to an MA or more (especially with the warrior cat those have very high demand and people will overpay alot for them)
- in my opinion its a fair trade if not over if you value the bun at 1 non -

[Sori]

Is this fair? Drink Me for Raven, Lolita, and a punk dog

[bunnifical]

I got these two list trades for my warriors. Which one seems fairer? Thanks so much!

Moonswirl Bun + Green-Fronted Holly + add

or

Cake Dog

[pibbys.palace]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92022543&userid=807904&signature=5_p1eNsuRh6UtIwaHh0Lcw

is this fair? i sell items for $1 btw (: but is the g.pig worth anything different? or is this fair.. please help if possible!