The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Space Avian]

thoughts on this1 & this2 ?

tia <3

First trade: Both 2009 rares so fair swap
Second trade: Each 2020 store pet is worth one 2010 rare, which is half a 2009 rare. The trade is pretty fair

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91795029&userid=999781&signature=UZf7ufEdr8-SIOvJ2Bo2ig

^ not sure on demand ^

this fair?

I've also received another trade. Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91930322&userid=999781&signature=olDzBZnl5b6PwH_b9yNxcAhttps://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?

First one is unfair to you
Malk elementals are four '09 rares each, which their side doesn't add up to
I can't see the second trade, did you copy the right link?

Any help? I'm not sure how many '09 rares the target dog is worth! any help would be greatly appreciated!

Their side is roughly 40 '09 rares if I did my math right
Target dog is 1.5-2 MA, which is 12-16 '09 rares

[teacorgi]

How is this ?
( a few recent pets n some items for a 2011 rare )
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91941924&userid=155021&signature=oH-4VumC2G5Slpo1MQSXXg

[Flicka]

Any idea if it's fair?

[Oblivion.]

Hello, is this fair?
Thank you in advance!

[Space Avian]

Hello, is this fair?
Thank you in advance!

Lolita is worth 1 non
BEG is 1-1.5 nons
Depending on your personal values this may or may not be fair

[.crossfire.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91937069&userid=729040&signature=Z6rhHiKBSLr-L4BHIsGodg

how's this? what should be added?

[AevisAeon]

X.
Is this fair? Thank you in advance!

[PokemonFan#1]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91942112&userid=1006990&signature=575oYXHnHWhRk4Eezk5mpw

Is this fair?

[Space Avian]

X.
Is this fair? Thank you in advance!

Unfair to you
Their pets are a lot more recent

[.crossfire.]

X.
Is this fair? Thank you in advance!

unfair to you. their side adds up to about a 2016 rare if you use the 2:1 ratio.

(the plushie is worth an '18 UC)