The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Saphiric]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91749234&userid=399134&signature=4eX6UDujTQMOgLU7Xay4eg

Recieved this offer and wanted to ask if it's fair to both sides. I know theirs is a store pet and my pup is a 2009 valentines rerelease with some other pets they want

id say unfair to there side, ive gotten 8-10 09 rares/a MA for that pet on there side. your side is 4-5 09 rares

Thank you! I added more to my side to try and make it more fair! Appreciate it! <3

[Southern sweetie]

Link

How’s this bid??
Not super familiar with list trades

[Vigil.]

Are the grapes a fair swap for the avocado?

[emma.]

Opinions on this? (:

[twenty one pilots]

is this fair demand-wise?

[CreamyLeather]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91751919&userid=842252&signature=3QtMn4iA4ZQ2hZA5WdAlYQ
Is this fair?

[ImThatRogue]

Thoughts on this? It's been a while since I've done any big list trades. I'd like to eventually auction some pets off for a mass amount of rare quantity since I'm running a bit low on rare fodder, so what would I be better off with, a bunch of store lists or a UR rat?

the store pets might be easyer to trade but the UR rat does fetch 0.5-1 non i would say its unfair to the rat by 2-4 MA

Ah well to be honest, the store pets would definitely be easier to trade but it depends on whether you're willing to be patient enough for it. Not many people accept rats due to how hard they are to trade, so you might be stuck with it for a while. That being said though, they are underpaying a lot, even by the Rat's lower value (0.75n)

Thank you! I'm hoping to get a huge quantity of rares ASAP for the holidays, so do you suggest I take the rat or keep my lists?

[AuroraButterflyx]

?, I might accept it 💝
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91752207&userid=796120&signature=MgONG-pxyo9MgheMFRxkLA

[Horror]

?, I might accept it 💝
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91752207&userid=796120&signature=MgONG-pxyo9MgheMFRxkLA

bandersnatch = at least a low advent though some value it up to a mid advent
their side is worth a high advent so they're overpaying still

[ThunderCedar]

?, I might accept it 💝
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91752207&userid=796120&signature=MgONG-pxyo9MgheMFRxkLA

Looks like a good trade. The butterfly wolf on your side goes for more around a mid advent (6-7 09 rares). Their side is worth a high advent (9 09 rares).

Edit: Horror beat me to it but I do agree :]