The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Horror]

Thoughts? IDK the demand of these pets.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91748069&userid=905642&signature=OFX-A6Pi0ujsQwmm3xcWOQ

With what they are giving you and what they want in return I would add either an item or two or an Uncommon pet from the the same year as the pet they are giving you. While yours is a VR from this year that breed of pet isn't released as often as the breed of pet they are giving you. Otherwise it's a pretty fair trade. A VR from last year would be worth a VR and a R from this year.

december 18th pets are rereleases, the guinea pig is 2010 while the horse is 2009 ^^
the tile pps horse is also a more valuable very rare because of when it changed rarities overall, so this trade was unfair to the horse side

[wonderlandfox]

Malk PPS Dragon = UR PPS Galaxy Cat?
Does either side have to add?
(I believe I heard the malk PPS is worth 1.5 nons when the cat is worth 1-1.5)
Thank you (:

[himarry 124]

how is the demand for androids atm? and is this fair? (i think it is- but not completely sure)

First they are offering you two of the same pet in the same trade which lowers the value unless you are hording. The 2011, 2012 and 2013 pets would only cover maybe one of your Androids. A 2010 VR is worth at least 1 VR & 1 R from 2011, with them wanting your Androids though (they are Store Pets) it would be at least 2 VR & 1 R from 2011 for just 1 of them

it is a fair trade honestly depending on how you value 0.5 non pets the sorb/androids are worth 5-7 MA they are offering 2 androids for a sorb and 6 MA's worth.

[himarry 124]

Malk PPS Dragon = UR PPS Galaxy Cat?
Does either side have to add?
(I believe I heard the malk PPS is worth 1.5 nons when the cat is worth 1-1.5)
Thank you (:

the malk is 1.5 and the cat is 1-1.5 but i think its a fair swap get a second opinion though

[Amberheart]

Mmm what do you guys think? trades/viewtrade.php?id=91748952&userid=270680&signature=uVfkuLr0P7nVGO_XtHa4hg

[GODDESS]

Mmm what do you guys think? trades/viewtrade.php?id=91748952&userid=270680&signature=uVfkuLr0P7nVGO_XtHa4hg

your side is definitely overing for many reasons. just 1 of the 2010 rares on your side covers the storepet, and the rests of the old uncommons/rares exceeds the worth of their side, even if you just traded 1 2010 rare and 9 of the 2011 uncommons youd be overtrading still. id suggest removing all of the 2011-2013 uncommons/rares

[Asougi]

how is the demand for androids atm? and is this fair? (i think it is- but not completely sure)

First they are offering you two of the same pet in the same trade which lowers the value unless you are hording. The 2011, 2012 and 2013 pets would only cover maybe one of your Androids. A 2010 VR is worth at least 1 VR & 1 R from 2011, with them wanting your Androids though (they are Store Pets) it would be at least 2 VR & 1 R from 2011 for just 1 of them

I think miss iruma's side is the one with the quantity ^^
Having multiple of the same pet isn't a detriment. Even if you're a collector and only want one of each pet, the purple heart huskies are popular and good for trading so that doesn't matter.

I'd say it's fair. The androids are worth a sorb each, so minus the obvious blue sorb, I value your side as:
Carousel @1.5 MA + T7 MA + T7 MA + cake dog @2 MA = 5.5 MA. Sorbs are commonly valued at 6-7 MA

[ImThatRogue]

Thoughts on this? It's been a while since I've done any big list trades. I'd like to eventually auction some pets off for a mass amount of rare quantity since I'm running a bit low on rare fodder, so what would I be better off with, a bunch of store lists or a UR rat?

the store pets might be easyer to trade but the UR rat does fetch 0.5-1 non i would say its unfair to the rat by 2-4 MA

Ah well to be honest, the store pets would definitely be easier to trade but it depends on whether you're willing to be patient enough for it. Not many people accept rats due to how hard they are to trade, so you might be stuck with it for a while. That being said though, they are underpaying a lot, even by the Rat's lower value (0.75n)

Thank you! I'm hoping to get a huge quantity of rares ASAP for the holidays, so do you suggest I take the rat or keep my lists?

[xXDegTheCollieXx]

is this fair? thank u in advance <3

[Vigil.]

Which is better for my July lioness?
bid 1bid 2bid 3bid 4bid5