The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[boodles]

I got an offer for items recently and I have literally no clue how to value them. They are my 2010 easter items and I am still clueless... Here's the offer
Any opinion is appreciated even if you are unsure

Thank you in advance!

I don’t know a ton about the value of items but I do know animal eggs 1-4 are worth ex-list pets. I’d be suspicious that animal egg 5 is also worth quite a bit, maybe at least an advent/sept list? Animal eggs are one of the most sought after items, people love collecting them. I’d personally hold on to them. I don’t see anything on their side that would be a considered a “valuable” item.

[himarry 124]

I got an offer for items recently and I have literally no clue how to value them. They are my 2010 easter items and I am still clueless... Here's the offer
Any opinion is appreciated even if you are unsure

Thank you in advance!

I don’t know a ton about the value of items but I do know animal eggs 1-4 are worth ex-list pets. I’d be suspicious that animal egg 5 is also worth quite a bit, maybe at least an advent/sept list? Animal eggs are one of the most sought after items, people love collecting them. I’d personally hold on to them. I don’t see anything on their side that would be a considered a “valuable” item.

i agree you should find out what those items are worth, the number 1 egg is worth 2 nons dont know how much difference is for 5 though

[CelticKitty]

Hi I got two offers and I'm so confused on what to do....
I need the CS$ or knock two Wl pets off....
1.trades/viewtrade.php?id=91748688&userid=397255&signature=le1gUtGZRJgXpAmnqffkJA

2.trades/viewtrade.php?id=91748318&userid=397255&signature=vlFiOln2ygdE0_Zw2Gd8DQ
I'm not sure I want to give up Zach but its a mallow!
Which one is fair to me? Thank you for your time!

[himarry 124]

Hi I got two offers and I'm so confused on what to do....
I need the CS$ or knock two Wl pets off....
1.trades/viewtrade.php?id=91748688&userid=397255&signature=le1gUtGZRJgXpAmnqffkJA

so its a fair offer, the UR cucumber is 1 non and 1200-1600 C$ is a non so they are offering 2 nons. the pps zebra is worth 1.5-2 nons so its a solid offer but get a second opinion

[tony stark]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91747801&userid=308850&signature=_YswXKsTtjy7fPWEXI8eRg

I used to be experienced in the value of lists, but I've been inactive for awhile and seem to be rusty. How has the value of the red cerb changed? About how many nons is it worth? Is this trade worth it, or could I get more?

red cerb is 3.5-4 nons. their side is around 4-4.5. they're overpaying.

[dizi_]

Thoughts? IDK the demand of these pets.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91748069&userid=905642&signature=OFX-A6Pi0ujsQwmm3xcWOQ

[Spine]

how is the demand for androids atm? and is this fair? (i think it is- but not completely sure)

[LemonadeQueen]

Will the Red Cerberus be easier to trade off than the Drink Me? I’m unsure how much it usually goes for, is this a fair swap?

red cerb is only 3.5-4 nons. drink me is 6. the kitsune on their side doesn't cover the gap. unfair to you ^^

Ah ty!

[sour patch.]

I'm currently having an auction for my UR cat, so I was wondering if I could get some help on these trades.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Are any of these fair, and which offer would be the best so far? Thank you so much for any help, I really appreciate it! <3

Could I also get some help with this trade for my UR aussie? The bigger pets are the BMD and skeleton PPS. Thank you!

[CaliAmbrose]

how is the demand for androids atm? and is this fair? (i think it is- but not completely sure)

First they are offering you two of the same pet in the same trade which lowers the value unless you are hording. The 2011, 2012 and 2013 pets would only cover maybe one of your Androids. A 2010 VR is worth at least 1 VR & 1 R from 2011, with them wanting your Androids though (they are Store Pets) it would be at least 2 VR & 1 R from 2011 for just 1 of them