The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Redbird]

Hello!
Is this a fair trade?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91551668&userid=631204&signature=1w4O2aU0mYzJQyPZloZ9UQ
Thank you so much for your help!

Edit: would this be fair? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91561314&userid=631204&signature=ysLK7zSteS0Cv9EZnPQASA

1. Fair
2. Unfair to you based on rarity, very unfair to you based on demand

[☠puppy gutz!☠]

xxx i sent this out and i wanna make sure i'm not underpaying for their side! :3c ty in advance for the help!

When it comes to mass trades of lower rarity pets, it's a bit up to the individual. I generally consider things pretty fair in about a three year range when it's newer years. So a 2020 common = 2019 common =/< 2018 common. If 2015 or older, I'd maybe start considering older years 1.5x the worth of the newer year, and 2012/2011 or older, the 2:1.

So anyway, I can really only give you my OPINION on this trade. Given that there are several staff pets on their side and none of their pets are newer than 2017 while many of yours are from this year, I'd say you're underpaying a bit. The degree by which you're underpaying is up to you two.

tyvm! can i get a second opinion? (@ mods sorry for reposting. i deleted it bc i thought i accidentally reposted on the same page but i,, didn't)

[bugbaby]

xxx i sent this out and i wanna make sure i'm not underpaying for their side! :3c ty in advance for the help!

your older uncommons for their higher number of uncommons, staff pets are not really worth more than normal rarities of their year (with the exception of the shima longtail from 2009) and you do have 4 old uncommons so the sides balance out
i agree with redbird though that these trades often come down to preference because everyone has a different method on how they measure the worth of bulk recent uncommon and under pets

[Goner.]

would this be fair?
purple toxic = bmd ?

thank you~

[bugbaby]

would this be fair?
purple toxic = bmd ?

thank you~

rarity wise it is fair as both are worth 0.5 nons but the bmd has a much higher demand and can get even more than 0.5 especially if it is td

[Punky*]

How about this?. I’m horrible with item trades

[Roonie-Roe]

Not sure what these store pets are currently going for... Would this be a fair enough trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91551606&userid=121&signature=Mewuo3QUko3w2MUyOd3q0A

[bugbaby]

How about this?. I’m horrible with item trades

the oldest items you have are from a 2014 event and are worth a 2014 uncommon each, and add up to about 1 2012 rare
everything else is smaller/more recent, i didn't do the math exactly but they should add up to at least another 2012 rare and by 2:1 your side is worth a 2011 rare. bulk trades are often down to preference but it seems fair

Not sure what these store pets are currently going for... Would this be a fair enough trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91551606&userid=121&signature=Mewuo3QUko3w2MUyOd3q0A

the 2012 store pet goes for 250-275 c$ usually and can sometimes go for even more, if you removed the 2016 store pet it would be fair but right now their side is under

[Infinitesimal]

is this trade fair? I'm not very good with knowing the rarities of older pets.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91514148&userid=787111&signature=JDySHOQtsNqXAmHzs7l3Rw

[Inari Rose]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91568649&userid=5753&signature=sk98iIAeDQIQfNUlS5AaPw

I've been out of the game for a bit!
Is this a fair trade? Do the items make it worth it?

EDIT: this one as well?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91568786&userid=5753&signature=_LLRew2ILG3JNVAcjP8epw