The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[☠puppy gutz!☠]

xxx i sent this out and i wanna make sure i'm not underpaying for their side! :3c ty in advance for the help!

[Toonafish]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91555642&userid=221635&signature=nCn-b65wEbd2opWotrVxxw
2009 very rare for 2012 very rare store pet is this fair ?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91555642&userid=221635&signature=nCn-b65wEbd2opWotrVxxw
2009 very rare for 2012 very rare store pet is this fair ? Please help!

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91555642&userid=221635&signature=nCn-b65wEbd2opWotrVxxw
2009 very rare for 2012 very rare store pet is this fair ?

Can anyone help? This is a big deal trade to me

Unfair to you. The peppermint horse is a low advent list, and while the carousel horse used to be a low advent list, it now goes for a mid-high advent.

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91555642&userid=221635&signature=nCn-b65wEbd2opWotrVxxw
2009 very rare for 2012 very rare store pet is this fair ?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91555642&userid=221635&signature=nCn-b65wEbd2opWotrVxxw
2009 very rare for 2012 very rare store pet is this fair ? Please help!

Please only post your trade once per page

[petshoplove]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91567285&userid=663112&signature=P95jTjMu1uTCGJAjLwNXvg
Is this fair? I have no idea C: thanks!

[Redbird]

xxx i sent this out and i wanna make sure i'm not underpaying for their side! :3c ty in advance for the help!

When it comes to mass trades of lower rarity pets, it's a bit up to the individual. I generally consider things pretty fair in about a three year range when it's newer years. So a 2020 common = 2019 common =/< 2018 common. If 2015 or older, I'd maybe start considering older years 1.5x the worth of the newer year, and 2012/2011 or older, the 2:1.

So anyway, I can really only give you my OPINION on this trade. Given that there are several staff pets on their side and none of their pets are newer than 2017 while many of yours are from this year, I'd say you're underpaying a bit. The degree by which you're underpaying is up to you two.

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91567285&userid=663112&signature=P95jTjMu1uTCGJAjLwNXvg
Is this fair? I have no idea C: thanks!

Fair, but on the low side of the value of that pet.

[MsCanadian]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91555642&userid=221635&signature=nCn-b65wEbd2opWotrVxxw
2009 very rare for 2012 very rare store pet is this fair ?

Can anyone help? This is a big deal trade to me

This is what I've found and is copied from the "how much is this pet worth?" Thread and is not my own opinion (:

an xtier 5 = 6-7 09' rares
Demand is up to you

2011 Stores: 1.5 mid advents, 10 ‘09 rare

2011 store pets are being valued at a September lists

However, if you're disregarding the list, then a 2011 store = 3-4 09 rares each

Again! I've just copied these! I'm not sure how updated these are ^^

If anyone wants to agree or disagree feel free! I hope I can be of come help ^^

Nevermind I'm gonna go die in a hole it's too early the pet is from 2012 brb x.x

[Miang]

Hello!
Is this a fair trade?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91551668&userid=631204&signature=1w4O2aU0mYzJQyPZloZ9UQ
Thank you so much for your help!

Edit: would this be fair? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91561314&userid=631204&signature=ysLK7zSteS0Cv9EZnPQASA

[MsCanadian]

Did not mean to quote this just edit so removing text for less spam