The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[re4]

Is this fair?

I have no idea what these items are worth. Thank you!

[bugbaby]

is this fair? I usually don’t trade my items?

most event items are worth an uncommon from their year, so the dress is worth a 2016 uncommon
5 c$ is already enough/over for a 2016 uncommon so they are offering slight overpay

[size=90]Is this fair?

I have no idea what these items are worth. Thank you!

those two items on your side are in the store, both in a set for 10 c$
valuing each plush at a 2014 uncommon each (worth about 4 c$) and adding the fact that you can buy your items in store anyways their side is over

is this fair?

this trade values the ur pineapple at 1100 c$ (the ur peas is stated to be worth the same), they are offering 50 c$ over that plus many recent rares. also a non is worth a little over 1000 in c$ i believe? the ur pineapple is worth a non so their offer is fair/over

Can somebody help with this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91536171&userid=16355&signature=PsFeaxM8-519l-eDgk86Dg

I'm not really sure what the worth is of the bunny so we both don't really know if this is a fair trade

sunjewel bun is worth 1.5-2 ma's
i have no idea what the valentine's lion is worth. but i know that it's one of the hardest lions to get besides the ur and august pps, i'll estimate it at 3 '09 rares but i could be very off (so i'd get a second opinion)
plus the t7 dog and 09 rare, it's a fair trade. i don't know whether the sunjewel bun trades closer to 1.5 or 2 ma's i just know bunnies don't usually have very good demand

I haven't traded big ticket items in a while and don't know what the strawberry's going for- so how is this trade?

the ur strawberry and marionette both go for 1.5 nons but the marionette has better demand, personally i wouldn't accept but it's down to preference

is this trade fair? i believe their pet is from october 2008 (mine is from christmas 2008)

any feedback is appreciated! (: yakitatoe

your pet is worth 6-7 '09 rares, on this list their pet is worth 1 ma. however, i don't see that pet usually considered at the same worth as a t7 dog and so i believe this is a fair swap/slight over to you

What do we think about this? They want me to add more but some of the bunnies are super old and I just am not sure. Thanks in advance!

you are offering HUGE overpay already with all of those older uncommons, at the very least don't add any more![/size]

[Flatterina]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91536179&userid=751686&signature=xGJCv-rQGGxUKf7EbzSTHw

Their Sunjewel for my UR Cat?
Thanks in advance!

[SkyPoppy]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91536327&userid=822941&signature=l6gXGLZ5Dnev25EjyBnC2A
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91536367&userid=822941&signature=0N6kLXgqNG646P4jzkzsmA

two more

[onion]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91534621&userid=350777&signature=LJSFuP8GhRidO8wmJfEuFg

mmmm? 50c$ fair for my kitty? ;;

[lordramen]

hey isthis fair demand and rarity wise? :3

also, is this one fair if it's one of their dogs for my side?

[Minibug ♡]

Hello!
I've been thinking about this trade for quite a bit now and I'm not sure if I should take it or wait? Any opinions?

I believe the PPS lion goes for 2 mid-advents? If so, that's really significant overpay- the alien dog and the card dog alone would be enough to reach 2 MAs.

Thank you, anyone else?
Also, how's this one too?

[miraclemilk]

is this fair for my ur strawberry?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91538042&userid=584969&signature=7KeBwdW2FQu8KZyXPFoQsw

[rxina]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91539444&userid=978798&signature=tZYlp_skqw7WL8QWKSJQZg

what would they have to add to make this fair for my pink balloon?

[Vigil.]

is this fair? I usually don’t trade my items?