The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[whitedane]

Is this fair?

[FrostbitenRoses]

is this fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91517903&userid=661506&signature=gBuSqhqxD_9onMboF_zQvQ

[Redbird]

Is this fair?

Unfair to them. The string horse and a few lions would be fair.

Is this fair?

Unfair to you. Even with how well-liked that glass dog is, they still need to add at least a 2011 rare.

Hi there! I would be thankful for any knowledge on whether this trade is considered fair.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91510004&userid=54485&signature=e1VWCQGFFDOv0wTHtcQfDA

Ehhh, more or less fair. I didn't do ALL the math because it would take a very long time, but it seems like the items roughly line up based on year and item type/demand. It might be slightly unfair to you, on a glance and mentally cancelling some stuff out. My suggestion would be to remove the animal egg (the unicorn/bat egg) and two of the dog/cat plushies in the first row on your side, and then the major imbalances of individual item value seem to be evened out better.

Feel free to ask for another opinion, since I don't have the chance to do the full item math I just know a lot of people really dislike helping with item trades.

[Redbird]

hi guys! was just needing an opinion of this trade>
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91522424&userid=668266&signature=7ewoe6HeYeAozmbZ138H8g

is this fair for both sides? thanks!

MAJORLY unfair to you. Their side isn't even worth the palomino tess horse on your side. Alternately, their side is fair if you remove the palomino tess horse, the pumpkin pie dog, and one other dog.

[.crossfire.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91402575&userid=729040&signature=QVKlqJfdlj8RTY22GpB0xw

is this fair to the other user? or is it over/underpay?

any help will be fantastic

[Redbird]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91418790&userid=9355&signature=WWoWHd-YUDQkK0AwoOfv5g is this fair?

their side= 12 '09 rares, i think the eggs and balloons are worth an 09 rare each and the stocking worth an 09 uncommon?
your side=8 09 rares
it's slight overpay or fair because i'm not 100% on the items and idk what kind of demand the sitting cats have

Help?

Unfair to you. I don't agree that the eggs are worth an 09 rare each, but don't know if there's an exact demand price attached to them. I agree that the balloons are worth an 09 rare each. IF I were on your side of the trade, I'd be comfortable completing it if I removed the two halloween dogs from your side*

*Do note this is my opinion: everyone may value older items a bit differently.

[Redbird]

would you guys consider this trade fair? thank you!

Yes, though the blue sortic has a bit more demand than the dog on their side, if you really boil it down. It's still unlikely to fetch any significant overpay with the average trader, though.

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91402575&userid=729040&signature=QVKlqJfdlj8RTY22GpB0xw

is this fair to the other user? or is it over/underpay?

any help will be fantastic

Removing 1-2 of the 08 PPS pups (depending on how you value a 2008 VR: I'm valuing the dogs at 3 09 rares each) and the dragon would make it fair.

[emiiwwy]

1
2
i'd like help with these two trades, please

[Redbird]

1
2
i'd like help with these two trades, please

**Aggressively spams the fair trade thread, apparently**

1) bad bad bad. Cancel cancel cancel.*
2) This is fair to slightly unfair to you. I'd probably ask for another 2010 rare, given that your particular dog was available with the set purchase only, but it's up to you and how much you like the pets on either side of your trade

*Corgi is worth at least a low advent list (3-4 09 rares), and often demand can dictate higher depending on the trading partner. Nothing in that trade is worth "anything" (comparatively) besides the fox