The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[toxxic]

Ending my auction today... would you take any of these bids, or ask for more added?

[PVRIS]

i just received this trade and i'm curious to know how fair it is, does the roadkill pony's demand match up to the santa hat cat or would it be smarter to keep the santa hat cat for demand purposes?
or, alternatively, how much would need to be added to the roadkill pony for the santa hat cat? (talking in '09 rares)

[Kabuski]

Ending my auction today... would you take any of these bids, or ask for more added?

The 2nd trade is over. If you value the store pets at a 2011 each, they’re over because that would all be fair for 1 09. But what makes it better is the fact there’s another 2020 store pet in there which wild technically be a fair swap depending on how you use the 3 month rule but they still added on top of that.

[goose]

Is this a fair trade? I know that the list pets have been cancelled but it's just confusing now.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85434217&userid=819691&signature=1IS4TUsSUtRnAxp4trSdAw

[toxxic]

Ending my auction today... would you take any of these bids, or ask for more added?

The 2nd trade is over. If you value the store pets at a 2011 each, they’re over because that would all be fair for 1 09. But what makes it better is the fact there’s another 2020 store pet in there which wild technically be a fair swap depending on how you use the 3 month rule but they still added on top of that.

Question since I'm still learning with store pets: does the fact that mine are VR count for anything? Like when you say the 2020 would be a fair swap for 1 of mine, that's true even though its R for VR?

[Mindina]

Is this fair? XxX

[owl,]

Ending my auction today... would you take any of these bids, or ask for more added?

The 2nd trade is over. If you value the store pets at a 2011 each, they’re over because that would all be fair for 1 09. But what makes it better is the fact there’s another 2020 store pet in there which wild technically be a fair swap depending on how you use the 3 month rule but they still added on top of that.

Question since I'm still learning with store pets: does the fact that mine are VR count for anything? Like when you say the 2020 would be a fair swap for 1 of mine, that's true even though its R for VR?

I can’t weigh in here since I have a bid but I do want to say 2019 store pets are worth a mid 2010 each actually c: also it doesn’t really matter what the rarity is, aside from demand, all same year store pets are worth the same!

[nowafflecone]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91465797&userid=729447&signature=ofDJNYFHMg8HrV86wRwjGA

how is this? thank you!

[Jojo Bear]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91457714&userid=860974&signature=rnN-OiKXE-LcD2HWfXrQcA

Hey can anyone give me an opinion on this trade? Thank you to everyone who does!

Help anyone?

Needsome more opinions, please help

[toxxic]

I can’t weigh in here since I have a bid but I do want to say 2019 store pets are worth a mid 2010 each actually c: also it doesn’t really matter what the rarity is, aside from demand, all same year store pets are worth the same!

Perfect, that totally clears up my question! Thank you!!