The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Miang]

Hello!

I wanted to ask if this trade would be fair? I am still trying to figure out what more demanded/ex list pets are worth atm! If this is not fair, what am I missing/ what would I need to add?

(the 2019 rereleases are from 2010,
The vr nick is from 2009)
Thank you so much!

[holodog]

Could I get some help with these store pet trades?
(1)
(2)
For 1, my partner is willing to add C$ (40 is their initial offer). For 2 my partner said in their message they're also willing to add to their side. I don't usually like trading down in date (except I am seeking/allowing trade downs for the deer offered in 2) so I'm a bit unsure about these!

In number 1, the top is unfair to the bottom. To make it fair they would have to add another 2015 very rare or take out the 2015 VR & replace it with a 2014 VR.

In the 2nd one, the top again is unfair by 16 2019 very rares or equivalent.

The top row of store pets in the 2nd trade add up to a 2016 very rare. (2 x 2018 R = 1 2018 VR) + (1 VR 2018) + (1 VR 2017 = 2 2018 VR) = 3 VR 2018 = 1 VR 2016
That leaves 1 2019 VR for the top in exchange for the 2015 VR on the bottom which equals 16 2019 VRs

2 2019 VR = 2018 VR
4 2019 VR = 2017 VR
8 2019 VR = 2016 VR
16 2019 VR = 2015 VR

I did not add the CS$ in. They say a store pet grows by 5 CS$ each year I believe. The 40 CS$ would make up for the difference on the second one.

Thanks for the help but I don't really follow or agree with your rarity math, and the C$ was for the first trade not the second trade. I'm just overall confused by this advice ^^'

[FrostbitenRoses]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91159459&userid=661506&signature=GTCcoVJBGy4nCbts48m4Jw

[ChaoticJello]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91162963&userid=955940&signature=qyxRkEQ-M9ed_1HHaMn3ww

Is this fair?

[Miang]

Hello!

I wanted to ask if this trade would be fair? I am still trying to figure out what more demanded/ex list pets are worth atm! If this is not fair, what am I missing/ what would I need to add?

(the 2019 rereleases are from 2010,
The vr nick is from 2009)
Thank you so much!

[Fierceless]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91162963&userid=955940&signature=qyxRkEQ-M9ed_1HHaMn3ww

Is this fair?

NO! They're ripping you off so, so much!

[holodog]

Could I get a second opinion on these store pet trades? Thank you!
(1)
(2)
For 1, my partner is willing to add C$ (40 is their initial offer). For 2 my partner said in their message they're also willing to add to their side. I don't usually like trading down in date (except I am seeking/allowing trade downs for the deer offered in 2) so I'm a bit unsure about these!

[scifirenegade]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91152607&userid=984611&signature=AXK4hACTRS6I6vAKvDjnYA

Wanna know if this is considered fair? Thank you so much for your attention btw

[ahirked]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91162963&userid=955940&signature=qyxRkEQ-M9ed_1HHaMn3ww

Is this fair?

NO! They're ripping you off so, so much!

agreed.
2018 store = early 2010 rare
2010 r == 4 2010 uc == 8 2011 uc
their side only adds up to 2 2010 uc (since the 4 2012 uc = 2011 uc which makes 4 2011 uc).

[Lucida]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91152607&userid=984611&signature=AXK4hACTRS6I6vAKvDjnYA

Wanna know if this is considered fair? Thank you so much for your attention btw

From what I know for most people, unknown pet rarities count as an uncommon till they get their true rarity at the beginning of the next month. So rarity wise this is fair. But demand wise, the hamsters usually get less demand in comparison to cats and foxes. So that is up to you if you think the Halloween pet covers the rest of the demand.