The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[holodog]

Could I get some help with these store pet trades?
(1)
(2)
For 1, my partner is willing to add C$ (40 is their initial offer). For 2 my partner said in their message they're also willing to add to their side. I don't usually like trading down in date (except I am seeking/allowing trade downs for the deer offered in 2) so I'm a bit unsure about these!

[UnEva]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91163119&userid=728581&signature=2YyMmcLvSPVudxRwKZlA_g

is this fair ? please help

The top has more worth by two extra 2019 rares & two 2020 commons & one extra 2010 rares. On the bottom are two horses, one is a re-release October/2008 very rare Tess horse & a re-release horse that's a very rare 2009. The top would have been fair with the 2 2009 rares & 2 2010 rares. It is very close though & it depends how much you like the pets.

[tokyogrxce]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91163164&userid=728581&signature=YlmestwtOc4jrY1NvXtQfA

what about this one? someone please help

[UnEva]

Could I get some help with these store pet trades?
(1)
(2)
For 1, my partner is willing to add C$ (40 is their initial offer). For 2 my partner said in their message they're also willing to add to their side. I don't usually like trading down in date (except I am seeking/allowing trade downs for the deer offered in 2) so I'm a bit unsure about these!

In number 1, the top is unfair to the bottom. To make it fair they would have to add another 2015 very rare or take out the 2015 VR & replace it with a 2014 VR.

In the 2nd one, the top again is unfair by 16 2019 very rares or equivalent.

The top row of store pets in the 2nd trade add up to a 2016 very rare. (2 x 2018 R = 1 2018 VR) + (1 VR 2018) + (1 VR 2017 = 2 2018 VR) = 3 VR 2018 = 1 VR 2016
That leaves 1 2019 VR for the top in exchange for the 2015 VR on the bottom which equals 16 2019 VRs

2 2019 VR = 2018 VR
4 2019 VR = 2017 VR
8 2019 VR = 2016 VR
16 2019 VR = 2015 VR

I did not add the CS$ in. They say a store pet grows by 5 CS$ each year I believe. The 40 CS$ would make up for the difference on the second one.

[This Is Halloween]

are my 4 store pets fair for their 3 store pets?

I did some research and came to the conclusion that two of my ‘15 pets (early ‘09 each) equal out to one of their ‘14 (2 ‘09 rares worth). Then the other two are about 3-ish months apart.

I appreciate if anyone could let me know if I’m correct or if there’s anything I can be corrected on! Thank you!

[UnEva]

are my 4 store pets fair for their 3 store pets?

I did some research and came to the conclusion that two of my ‘15 pets (early ‘09 each) equal out to one of their ‘14 (2 ‘09 rares worth). Then the other two are about 3-ish months apart.

I appreciate if anyone could let me know if I’m correct or if there’s anything I can be corrected on! Thank you!

This trade is fair totally!

The bottom you add two of the 2015 VR and that equals one 2014 VR, they put in a 2014 VR, then that leaves one 2015 VR.....which is the exact same as the top.

[This Is Halloween]

are my 4 store pets fair for their 3 store pets?

I did some research and came to the conclusion that two of my ‘15 pets (early ‘09 each) equal out to one of their ‘14 (2 ‘09 rares worth). Then the other two are about 3-ish months apart.

I appreciate if anyone could let me know if I’m correct or if there’s anything I can be corrected on! Thank you!

This trade is fair totally!

The bottom you add two of the 2015 VR and that equals one 2014 VR, they put in a 2014 VR, then that leaves one 2015 VR.....which is the exact same as the top.

Thank you so much! <3

[UnEva]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91163164&userid=728581&signature=YlmestwtOc4jrY1NvXtQfA

what about this one? someone please help

The top is unfair to the bottom 2008 VR Tess Horse. The top only amounts to - 5 2011 rares.

5 x 2011 R (& R 2020) = 1 2010 VR & 1 2011 R & 15 CS$

4 x 2011R = 2010 R
1 2011 R & 2020 R + 15 CS$ = 2009 R?

In my opinion with the 15 CS$ & the left over 2011 rare & 2020 R + 2010 R might just barely make a 2009 VR. It would take another 2009 Rare or equivalent to add up to a 2009 VR.

[UnEva]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91163164&userid=728581&signature=YlmestwtOc4jrY1NvXtQfA

what about this one? someone please help

The top is unfair to the bottom 2008 VR Tess Horse. The top only amounts to - 5 2011 rares.

5 x 2011 R (& R 2020) = 1 2010 VR & 1 2011 R & 15 CS$

4 x 2011R = 2010 R
1 2011 R & 2020 R + 15 CS$ = 2009 R?

In my opinion with the 15 CS$ & the left over 2011 rare & 2020 R + 2010 R might just barely make a 2009 VR. It would take another 2009 Rare or equivalent to add up to a 2009 VR.

[UnEva]

are my 4 store pets fair for their 3 store pets?

I did some research and came to the conclusion that two of my ‘15 pets (early ‘09 each) equal out to one of their ‘14 (2 ‘09 rares worth). Then the other two are about 3-ish months apart.

I appreciate if anyone could let me know if I’m correct or if there’s anything I can be corrected on! Thank you!

This trade is fair totally!

The bottom you add two of the 2015 VR and that equals one 2014 VR, they put in a 2014 VR, then that leaves one 2015 VR.....which is the exact same as the top.

Thank you so much! <3

No problem at all! Have a wonderful day/night!