The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sapphirelion]

Need help! Is this fair to my trading partner? I'm not sure...

I don’t know if the pet on your side still has a high demand with it getting a rarity recently, but if it isn’t in high demand this is not fair to your trade partner, even if it was just the one 2019 rare on their side (there’d still be a year different between the 2 pets)

[Kabuski]

opinions?

[toxxic]

Fair for this 09 nick horse?

[Sorrell]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129760&userid=802873&signature=BJ8pJVPRdgCv59Pw3mWSxg

is this fair? I don't really know much about the ex-list

[Shado]

hi is this trade fair? thanks <3

[Howl's Moving Castle]

Is this fair for the cerberus?

Trade

red cer is 2-3 nons so its 2.5-3 worth so its up to you

edit: HOLD UP, thats a dog tag not a non dog. dog tag is 1.5-2+ 1 non so thats already max 3 so their over

[bugbaby]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129103&userid=724816&signature=6N9KzbiCK6DXPNCqEg-S5A

is this fair? they said they could add a few more rare butterfly wolves (i'm collecting them)

edit: i got another cheetah trade

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129817&userid=724816&signature=QFR_ovgFZm-5bK6Lvd-Rpg

[Sorrell]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129760&userid=802873&signature=BJ8pJVPRdgCv59Pw3mWSxg

is this fair? I don't really know much about the ex-list

also this one- trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129781&userid=802873&signature=Id-NwTzHVMZidIKvn6sISw

[Faux]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129760&userid=802873&signature=BJ8pJVPRdgCv59Pw3mWSxg

is this fair? I don't really know much about the ex-list

also this one- trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129781&userid=802873&signature=Id-NwTzHVMZidIKvn6sISw

Hm I'm on the other side of the First Trade so you'd want another, unbiased opinion but here's the general Values:
UR Tiger: 6 Nons

Sunjewel: 3 Nons
Moonswirl: 2.5-3 Nons (Usually 2.5)
Total: 5.5 - 6 Nons+ the C$

For the second it'd be

Grinner: 2 MAs (x3, so 0.5 Nons)
UR Foal: 1 Non
Sunjewel: 3 Nons
CEG: 1-1.5 Nons
Total: Also 5.5 -6 Nons

[Howl's Moving Castle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129760&userid=802873&signature=BJ8pJVPRdgCv59Pw3mWSxg

is this fair? I don't really know much about the ex-list

also this one- trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129781&userid=802873&signature=Id-NwTzHVMZidIKvn6sISw

ur tiger is 5-6 nons.


trade 1:
sunjewl 3 non but bad demand
moonswirl is 2 nons



Trade 2:
ceg is 1-1.5 non
ur foal 1 non but bad demand
sunjewl 3 non but bad demand
the ginners are 6 ma's all together but bad demand

personally would decline