The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Mossia]

Is this fair to both sides demand wise? trades/viewtrade.php?id=91112716&userid=982961&signature=4S9YL_ScSkPH7dqwtWNSzg

thank you so much in advance!

[Rowesta]

i cant even decide actually becuase i suck at item worthh
but I think a no? just want to confirm trades/viewtrade.php?id=91115896&userid=1001260&signature=x2rkHAyPb6SKi5AMZy9Rpw

[darling feathers]

help please

xxx
feathers

[.rin okumura.]

Would this be fair? I am unsure about what the Phoenix is worth C$ wise. Thank you in advance

[AlexBlu]

1. They are overpaying on their side (considering all pets from both sides are from 2020)


2. Between the year differences I believe their side is overpaying (they have older pets)
Here’s a c$ estimate comparison of both sides:

Theirs:
Pps dog: 16c$
Uncommon dog: 1.5c$
Common dog: .5c$

16+1.5+.5
Total: 18c$

Yours:
15c$
Common dog: .25c$
Unknown rarity event trade-in lion: unknown, but normally event trade in pets can become uncommon-rare so maybe: .5-1c$

15+.25+.5= 15.75c$
Or
15+.25+1= 16.25

Thank you; ^^

Could I also get a second opinion?

[Vanrouge]

It's been a long time since I traded properly, is this a good trade? (Including date swap)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91112118&userid=429963&signature=Rl2wr43HI3L5bfSzRwEF6A

Can I get a second opinion on this please?

[.rin okumura.]

Would this be fair? I am unsure about what the Phoenix is worth C$ wise. Thank you in advance

[Rowesta]

i cant even decide actually becuase i suck at item worthh
but I think a no? just want to confirm trades/viewtrade.php?id=91115896&userid=1001260&signature=x2rkHAyPb6SKi5AMZy9Rpw

[Howl's Moving Castle]

It's been a long time since I traded properly, is this a good trade? (Including date swap)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91112118&userid=429963&signature=Rl2wr43HI3L5bfSzRwEF6A

Can I get a second opinion on this please?

i would do it, punk dog is worth .5 nons

[Owlmania]

Could someone help me with this?
I am mostly looking to find out if the rares are a good trade for my store pets