The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ChrysanthemumT.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90118277&userid=818443&signature=fChUtYYutaivVFrrV1c5vA
would this trade be fair

hi i still haven't gotten a response

hey it's been two days and i haven't gotten a reply

No, your is a 2008 re-release.

[nicole]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90118277&userid=818443&signature=fChUtYYutaivVFrrV1c5vA
would this trade be fair

hi i still haven't gotten a response

hey it's been two days and i haven't gotten a reply

this isn't fair, your dog is a rerelease from 2008, and theirs is a rerelease from 2009. Their side adds up to 2 09 rares, 1 2013 rare, and 1 2015 rare. Your side is about 4 09 rares, if you value an 08 VR like that. It's unfair to you

[meimopotato]

Could I have some opinions on these trades please?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90118085&userid=847277&signature=JEWVOX3jLpGVKlroUSoQow
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90114856&userid=847277&signature=x55ji8M1kWrcTQg_achR_g

Thank you!

and these ones as well
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90135354&userid=847277&signature=yUxP8WtGQG1FhboAuJBMkw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90128215&userid=847277&signature=gcvlqdEWDjDQOT4NsI09DA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90135470&userid=847277&signature=82ClgUGm721buJP790LnvQ

[nasa]

Asking again about this trade. Thank you in advance <3

[demus]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90118277&userid=818443&signature=fChUtYYutaivVFrrV1c5vA
would this trade be fair

hi i still haven't gotten a response
hey it's been two days and i haven't gotten a reply

this isn't fair, your dog is a rerelease from 2008, and theirs is a rerelease from 2009. Their side adds up to 2 09 rares, 1 2013 rare, and 1 2015 rare. Your side is about 4 09 rares, if you value an 08 VR like that. It's unfair to you

thank you for the help. what should they add to their side to make it fair?

[Spearow]

Hiya, can I get some help with this?
Pet Tags;
Chestnut arabian
hyena advent (t7)
timberwolf advent (t7)

Don't really know if I'm under or over, advice?

[Viridian Dragonkoi]

Thoughts about this trade please?

[Shrimplybad]

Thoughts about this trade please?

I counted ~61 '09 rares(since most of the '08 ones were extended release), which is about half a non. The red toxic goes for .25-5 nons, and while there isn't much on the mint horse, it's generally going for around .5-1 non. Your side is .75-1 non, and theirs is .5-1 non.

[Kabuski]

Is the ur strawberry cake hard to trade?
Just want some opinions on this, I feel like I’m over and that the pets (other than liontail) may be hard to trade

I personally value nons at 1,400

[Kabuski]

Any help with these trades would be appreciated: ✿ // ✿

I believe Eros is low advent in worth (4-5 09’s) and white feb is also a low advent (probably t1)
1St. It’s unfair to them, you’re side is about 2.5-3 09’s
2nd. Fair/over, the bun goes for a t1 as far as I’ve seen