The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[dannydevito]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90109290&userid=140916&signature=mjh8qZExNsklTr6ADej0fw

this feels like a good trade but i’d love a second opinion

[Shrimplybad]

Odd question, but how far off would an offer of the Skeleton PPS, Nick, Lexi, Pink, and Light Cake Dogs, and Purple String Horse be from a Clockwork Bun[valuing at 1.5nons]? Preferably in '09 rares. Thanks in advance!

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90109290&userid=140916&signature=mjh8qZExNsklTr6ADej0fw

this feels like a good trade but i’d love a second opinion

If you’re happy with it, go for it! However, the pets on their side are relatively low-demand, and the dogs on your side are quite high-demand. This is not a trade I would personally accept because those staff dogs are quite likely to at least fetch uncommons and (Very occasionally) rares from their respective year.

[Ucanthandleme]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90109290&userid=140916&signature=mjh8qZExNsklTr6ADej0fw

this feels like a good trade but i’d love a second opinion

Just for reference I'm calculating this like 2 commons = 1 uncommon, 2 uncommons = 1 rare ect.

Just off the bat highly unfair to you.

Their side is about
3 2015 rares and 1 2015 uncommon

Just one of your uncommons is a overpay so I wouldn't take this. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, or get a second opinion.

Edit: I agree with the above

[crucifying.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90110723&userid=551977&signature=cUZRbOhEPrdKmKKy3EL6XA

is this fair?

[moon child]

would this be fair? (replace the ur malk dog with a black Advent)
how much is each side worth?

[ghosties]

can anyone tell me if this is fair or what would be needed to be added to either side to make it fair?

[sammyanddaisy]

I don't know how to rate items so is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90110748&userid=166678&signature=Zl2wuxvk3nkGPrd4EOOtpw
Thank you!

[Redbird]

I don't know how to rate items so is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90110748&userid=166678&signature=Zl2wuxvk3nkGPrd4EOOtpw
Thank you!

Items are worth ~1 uncommon from the same year. The regular saddles and bridles aren't worth much on their own, but the faire hoods are worth about one 2011 uncommon each, and the sleigh bridle would be worth an uncommon from its year (I can't recall when that one was released off the top of my head). Therefore, this trade is unfair to you. The degree of unfairness depends on how high you value a 2015 rare versus a 2011 uncommon/rare.

[Kabuski]

Saying a green liontail is worth around 2(?) nons this seems a bit unfair to me, but opinions anyway?