The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Shrimplybad]

Thoughts? Thanks in advance!

[houndoom]

Thoughts? Thanks in advance!

the two guardians are unnecessary in my opinion and i would not do this.

[honeycreeper]

could I have some opinions on some c$ trades? which would be best? thanks for any advice!

xx xx xx

honey

[dannydevito]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90105305&userid=140916&signature=a2meoiSLud8fdBVh5F3tUw


trades/viewtrade.php?id=90107836&userid=140916&signature=idk9a6FBBMg8WdopPXdebA


are these fair? pls help

The second is solidly unfair to you. Those faire bwolves do fetch decent demand, but the 2 to 1 rule tends to be pretty solidly accepted, at least as far as 2011 and older pets go. Their side only is worth 3 of the rare dogs on your side.

The first trade is also unfair to you. I don't personally feel a 2:1 year gap ratio is particularly relevant or fair for more recent years' pets, but even disregarding the "rule", it's unfair to you. The demand of the kitsune is also quite decent. They'd have to add several pets to their side, but ultimately balancing it depends on WHICH pets they're adding.

thank you so much, this helps a lot..!

[p&uline]

here i am again ;3
I'm sorry but i'm too bad with big trades :c

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90108317&userid=953996&signature=SvuZtsjz5N6jcUMWUEHLgw

[dannydevito]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90107959&userid=140916&signature=Uov3mRdu9hu9DG7ClvcfmQ


trades/viewtrade.php?id=90106706&userid=140916&signature=ZK2mDwr4XDGP_BnNNOTt1g

do these seem fair?
pls help i’m a newb at trading ;;

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90107959&userid=140916&signature=Uov3mRdu9hu9DG7ClvcfmQ


trades/viewtrade.php?id=90106706&userid=140916&signature=ZK2mDwr4XDGP_BnNNOTt1g

do these seem fair?
pls help i’m a newb at trading ;;

The first one with all the rares is technically overpay on their side. However, the pets on your side have better demand, generally speaking. If you're interested in the pets on their side and are happy with trading your pets for theirs, then go for it. If you're less interested in the pets they're offering, that's totally fair. Many people will not trade a dog for a rat; it all depends on what you like.

For the second trade, many people say that 2:1 is fair for year gaps (a 2009 rare is worth two 2010 rares, etc). When it comes to newer years, I don't personally find this particularly relevant or fair for logistical reasons about number of players and number of pets. So, on a 2:1 standpoint, this trade is significantly unfair to you. On a true rarity/value standpoint, I'd say it's still unfair to you, but less so. They'd have to add more to their side either way, or I would (PERSONALLY, if it were my trade) be comfortable trading one of the rabbits for the pets on their side.

[iago.]

Really really really need help on these ASAP! which one is best?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90088189&userid=964094&signature=lCZiUJd5wtcjdAXea-Greg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90087939&userid=964094&signature=Ukfi8h55R8Kmd3lA54Jnaw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90070237&userid=964094&signature=DyYoswMiRA6l24jhtIgxyg

I would prefer a PM because I tend to lose pages but replies are fine too! Thank you for your time!

[Redbird]

could I have some opinions on some c$ trades? which would be best? thanks for any advice!

xx xx xx

honey

I'm not really going to speak on true fairness/value here, since I don't personally value the cake dogs as highly as some people. HOWEVER... I can tell you that the trade with the purple bunny on their side is worth the most.

[onion]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90104694&userid=350777&signature=hW2V8QLxBzdTKEO9JD58Tw

hows this look to my spider? :)