The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ghosties]

opinions on this? we dont follow the list

[iago.]

thank you for everyone’s help this far! i just got this trade that i really really need help on!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90069254&userid=964094&signature=B3n9RGau2t_U4N2VcSq0iQ

should i take it?

[FOUND VERDICT]

thank you for everyone’s help this far! i just got this trade that i really really need help on!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90069254&userid=964094&signature=B3n9RGau2t_U4N2VcSq0iQ

should i take it?

the green liontail trades for 2-2.5 nons (though closer to 2)
your side adds up to 2-2.75 depending how you value the ceg (1-1.5) /pink sorbet (0.5-0.75)

[chromatica]

is this fair?

[DarknessANDLight]

This trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90066370&userid=926207&signature=Y4Z6pCDMClsJWivXbh_NGw
I thought it was 100-150 09 rares to one non, but I'm not sure, Looking for a Opinion or two

98-100 09’s is worth 1 non
I counted 150 09 rares (no demand) and for simplicity I’ll say 10 09’s for all the uncommons and commons
That’s 160 09’s without demand
There were some high demand rares like the warrior cats and some of the 09 vr’s which typically go twice their worth, I’m not going back to count them, so I’m gonna say add on another 20 09’s for demand that’s 180 09 rares with demand., this would be unfair to you.

One final Opinion?

[Draconica2014]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90045021&userid=878037&signature=G7UlNdhDpKIEXe3fZZpJeQ
2nd op?

[chromatica]

this or this?

[Kabuski]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90045021&userid=878037&signature=G7UlNdhDpKIEXe3fZZpJeQ
2nd op?

Unfair to you
although the scarf is from 2011, it probably be worth about a 2011 uncommon.

2 2011 uncommons *can* be fair if you use the 2:1 rule, but i'm going to use the 4-5:1 rule

[♡HappyAlpaca♡]

Was this worth it?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90073198&userid=983291&signature=W-2mnt6kwOUQDPumhIV2nA

[Kabuski]

Was this worth it?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90073198&userid=983291&signature=W-2mnt6kwOUQDPumhIV2nA

It was overpay on their part since we don't know their values atm