The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Shrimplybad]

Hello! I maked a auction for my pps rose and i think what is fair and better?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90066069&userid=994729&signature=4692xdvGYia4015DidlFyQ
Or
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90011254&userid=994729&signature=-jWu5kS7AZP45aiXA_NwQg
and this is fair?
if all are fair, what is better?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90066766&userid=994729&signature=p08mjnCSbrIFvNzx_MiZ_g

i really need help...

Rose PPS is worth .25 nons, or 3-4 ma's
Trade 1: Santa Cat, Nick Cake Dog, Green Grinner + 2 '10 rares. Adds up to 4ma's + an '09.
Trade 2: Dark Leopard is 2 ma's, Kitsune is 1. The store pets, zodiac, and warrior add up to ~11 '09 rares. Adds up to 4 ma's + 4 '09s.
Trade 3: Pink punk dog. Worth .5 nons, or 6-7 ma's.
I'd definitely take the third.

[re4]

How's This?

I've been pretty inactive for a while now and have no idea what patches go for anymore. Please respond ASAP, Thank you! <3

[Shrimplybad]

How's This?

I've been pretty inactive for a while now and have no idea what patches go for anymore. Please respond ASAP, Thank you! <3

Terminology in case you've missed it:
MA = mid advent. A pet worth the same as a tier 5-7 on the old advent list. Worth 7-8 '09 rares.
Non = A pet worth the same as the old non tier. Worth 10-12 ma's.

Patchwork is worth 1.5 nons. The UR Malk Dog is worth 1-1.5, and the alien dog is worth a mid advent. If you value the malk at the high end, it's slight overpay. If you value it at the low end, it's underpay.

[blurry_cat1]

Its last from one person
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90067628&userid=994729&signature=V-gqz-Wv5TUJcgHICQqp0w
And this is fair? This is better than other i get?

[DarknessANDLight]

This trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90066370&userid=926207&signature=Y4Z6pCDMClsJWivXbh_NGw
I thought it was 100-150 09 rares to one non, but I'm not sure, Looking for a Opinion or two

98-100 09’s is worth 1 non
I counted 150 09 rares (no demand) and for simplicity I’ll say 10 09’s for all the uncommons and commons
That’s 160 09’s without demand
There were some high demand rares like the warrior cats and some of the 09 vr’s which typically go twice their worth, I’m not going back to count them, so I’m gonna say add on another 20 09’s for demand that’s 180 09 rares with demand., this would be unfair to you.

One final Opinion?

[Rbpuppy]

updated trade! please help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90068466&userid=964094&signature=FMVHi78ZjDzSUOL5Nz9Nlw

Your side is worth 2-2.5 Nons depending on how you value the CEG. A non alone is worth $1050 CS, so they’re short making this unfair to you.

[re4]

How's this?

Please respond ASAP, Thank you!

[XxDragonScalesxX]

Just looking to get some opinions on these 2 bids.
Bid 1
Bid 2

[snowdrake]

How's this?

Please respond ASAP, Thank you!

overpay by them. the squid doesn't really add much value to your side.

Just looking to get some opinions on these 2 bids.
Bid 1
Bid 2

both are unfair to you. bid one is worth about 32 09 rares (4.5 MAs) while the Kitsune set goes for a sorbet (5-6 MAs). the second bid is even more unfair, as their side only adds up to a bit more than 11 09 rares and the c$ definitely isn't enough to cover the gap.

[XxDragonScalesxX]

Just looking to get some opinions on these 2 bids.
Bid 1
Bid 2

both are unfair to you. bid one is worth about 32 09 rares (4.5 MAs) while the Kitsune set goes for a sorbet (5-6 MAs). the second bid is even more unfair, as their side only adds up to a bit more than 11 09 rares and the c$ definitely isn't enough to cover the gap.

Thank you! Could I get one more opinion?