The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[CalicoWolf]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89704523&userid=6076&signature=G8I2zhRCqS3yhLlD60hTwA
Thanks in advance

[aniuk]

Oops

Here’s the right link: trades/viewtrade.php?id=89774832&userid=987366&signature=UBPIHK2qC1GDUXxbHqDLLA


I just got another offer: trades/viewtrade.php?id=89774892&userid=987366&signature=FhEXHP-CXfnziXFKwhcvUg

Pls help!

i'm not positive how much the white feb (your dog) is worth, but i do know true dates and rereleases are technically worth the same. some users value true dates slightly more. so, as for the first offer, anything other than the white feb dog is overpay. you'd just be trading your true date for a rerelease (: any demand based on it being a true date is up to you and your trading partner.

-- as for the worth of the pet, it is technically only worth the 3 month rule, but gets significantly more due to demand.
here are some recent successful trades for the white february (the white dog on your side):
completed trade
completed trade
completed trade
after browsing the 'how much is this pet worth' thread, it seems malk elemental cats are worth 3-4 '09 rares.
personally, i feel you could get a better offer, but please get a second opinion on that if you can!

[ZeroToInfinity]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89786862&userid=849019&signature=nOkyxxK24BpBeOoOvQd63Q

Is this a fair trade? Only the two very rares are on my wishlist.

[VNKP]

Hi is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89786604&userid=985924&signature=pDaZyLG3ZVEYOm4qM6u6Aw

They're overpaying with 2 x 2014 rares for my 3 x 2020 rares right? Just need to be sure

Thank you!

[gigi2526]

Hi is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89786604&userid=985924&signature=pDaZyLG3ZVEYOm4qM6u6Aw

They're overpaying with 2 x 2014 rares for my 3 x 2020 rares right? Just need to be sure

Thank you!

Yeah, personally I think they are overpaying

[VNKP]

So would one 2014 rare and the other rpets do fine or would that still be overpay?

[aniuk]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89786862&userid=849019&signature=nOkyxxK24BpBeOoOvQd63Q

Is this a fair trade? Only the two very rares are on my wishlist.

no, this is very unfair to you.
your pet is from 2008, and is a very rare.

the very rares on their side are 2019 store pets, worth a mid 2010 rare each. that would make both of them worth about an '09 rare.
the two '11 rats added together = 1 '10 rare.
so, they're only offering one '09 and one '10 rare plus the '20 rare, when they'd need to be offering two '08 rares worth.

link to your pet's true date in the archive

[snowdrake]

is this a good offer?
does the GWJ easily trade for a non or does it struggle to get a non? how hard is it to trade off in general?

[ZeroToInfinity]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89786862&userid=849019&signature=nOkyxxK24BpBeOoOvQd63Q

Is this a fair trade? Only the two very rares are on my wishlist.

no, this is very unfair to you.
your pet is from 2008, and is a very rare.

the very rares on their side are 2019 store pets, worth a mid 2010 rare each. that would make both of them worth about an '09 rare.
the two '11 rats added together = 1 '10 rare.
so, they're only offering one '09 and one '10 rare plus the '20 rare, when they'd need to be offering two '08 rares worth.

link to your pet's true date in the archive

OK, thank you.

[snowdrake]

is this a good offer?
does the GWJ easily trade for a non or does it struggle to get a non? how hard is it to trade off in general?