The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SpookyMerlin]

Oml Ima bout to cry! They’re so nice!!! <3

[spirited away]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89768736&userid=813435&signature=FStSIm2q_WrXMPWx0rwZSg
been asking for a while please help

[VNKP]

Is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89784238&userid=985924&signature=Fbj8gt0tS6ArgRIo7y9QIw

If I have calculated correctly they have what is a 2016 rare plus an uncommon on their side? And if they do have a 2016 rare is that fair for my 3 rares from this year or are they overpaying ?

[musicgurl333]

Is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89784238&userid=985924&signature=Fbj8gt0tS6ArgRIo7y9QIw

If I have calculated correctly they have what is a 2016 rare plus an uncommon on their side? And if they do have a 2016 rare is that fair for my 3 rares from this year or are they overpaying ?

It depends on how you value the gap between years, and also rares/uncommons/commons. Personally, I go by 2VC=1 common and 3 commons =1 rare. Their side adds up to just over 2 ‘16 uncommons, so to me that doesn’t equal a ‘16 rare. As far as years, if you follow the doubling rule, the 1 ‘16 uncommon=2 ‘17 uncommons =4 ‘18 uncommons=8 ‘19 uncommons =16 ‘20 uncommons, which equals about 4-5 ‘20 rares. So it would be about overpay on their side. Personally though, I wouldn’t accept if it was me. I don’t agree with doubling pet values, and I think you could do better.

[VNKP]

Okay thank you! : )

[snowdrake]

is this a good offer?
does the GWJ easily trade for a non or does it struggle to get a non? how hard is it to trade off in general?

[Liv.]

Is a Skele PPS worth a Grey border collie advent and a mustard husky advent?

[ChrysanthemumT.]

Oops

Here’s the right link: trades/viewtrade.php?id=89774832&userid=987366&signature=UBPIHK2qC1GDUXxbHqDLLA


I just got another offer: trades/viewtrade.php?id=89774892&userid=987366&signature=FhEXHP-CXfnziXFKwhcvUg

[Rbpuppy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89782031&userid=998263&signature=6ik7oiaDiqWBGSDGZQU52Q Is this fair? Bc I really really want to accept it

Unfair to them, their pet is worth a 2010 rare

[ChrysanthemumT.]

Oops

Here’s the right link: trades/viewtrade.php?id=89774832&userid=987366&signature=UBPIHK2qC1GDUXxbHqDLLA


I just got another offer: trades/viewtrade.php?id=89774892&userid=987366&signature=FhEXHP-CXfnziXFKwhcvUg

Pls help!