The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[RED-Legacy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89780921&userid=900297&signature=27Awpon0Q5YrmzjMN0fP8A

I’m confused with what do do

basing this off of the 'how much is this pet worth in c$' guide,

A 2013 rare/very rare is worth around 12-15C$
A 2014 rare/very rare is worth around 10-12C$

they're offering an early-ish '14 + 2C$ for your mid '13.
going off of c$ values, your '13 is worth 12 c$ at the least, and theirs is worth 10 C$. they've added 2 C$ to close the gap. personally, i think it is fair going off of these values.

dogs have more demand than bunnies to some users, but the preference is up to you! i think the bunny is cute.

Your 2013 rare is worth two (2) 2014 rares. They are offering one, the 2C$ does not make up the difference. This is unfair to you.

[wlw]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89780921&userid=900297&signature=27Awpon0Q5YrmzjMN0fP8A

I’m confused with what do do

basing this off of the 'how much is this pet worth in c$' guide,

A 2013 rare/very rare is worth around 12-15C$
A 2014 rare/very rare is worth around 10-12C$

they're offering an early-ish '14 + 2C$ for your mid '13.
going off of c$ values, your '13 is worth 12 c$ at the least, and theirs is worth 10 C$. they've added 2 C$ to close the gap. personally, i think it is fair going off of these values.

dogs have more demand than bunnies to some users, but the preference is up to you! i think the bunny is cute.

Your 2013 rare is worth two (2) 2014 rares. They are offering one, the 2C$ does not make up the difference. This is unfair to you.

agree with red legacy, the 2C$ does not make up the difference. theyd have to add enough c$ to be worth a 2014 rare in order to make it up.

[owl,]

do you have any sources stating the '12 store pet is worth 1 non? I have never, ever, heard of them going for a non. everything i find says they're worth 1 midadvent, or 7-8 '09 rares. am i missing something here?

agree with aniuk, the fairy goats are definitely not 1 non

nope you guys are right! i just wrote it down wrong in my notes!! im so sorry about that, thank you for correcting me!

[spirited away]

fair?

[owl,]

is this fair?

thanksss

also this one thanksss

1; id say unfair to you. the bfw is worth a mid advent or 6-8 '09 rares while your growing strawberry dog is worth 6-7 '09 rares and the corgi store pet 3-4 '09 rares. at least they are getting an extra '09 rare, at most they are getting an extra 4 '09 rares. i would say removing the corgi would make it fair

[hollystar24]

got this trade not sure if items would be fair on this fox or not (I have duplicates of the items but I don't know what the fox maybe worth in items/pets) https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89734098&userid=362948&signature=VxLIrBhmrhF5eHjNY2vFSA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89735389&userid=362948&signature=NF1G4S-5WY-r1EWBa7_A2A and also this one

[suspicious]

is this fair?

thanksss

also this one thanksss

ah can i get a second opinion pleasee thanks

[Punky*]

Thoughts?
I’m just unsure

[CloudedJasper]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89641170&userid=856554&signature=5DijvA4hKTeLCgm-ujgM4w

[CreamyFloof]

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89781707&userid=868350&signature=HkdvVVmM1v9naRn-A7se9g