The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[wlw]

Fair? It’s already been accepted, but I think it’s fair. trades/viewtrade.php?id=89776960&userid=992747&signature=WuAsjznsngw2y7gp1F1kXQ

well, you did overpay with the added common, but not by much, so its pretty close to fair!

[mykola]

Hello, is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89780257&userid=989315&signature=SDqTLgq4aTlAxsZ56dYJeA

[owl,]

feel free to get second opinions as im not up to date with demand

Hello, is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89780257&userid=989315&signature=SDqTLgq4aTlAxsZ56dYJeA

looks like a slight overpay on their side as the pitbull is worth 1-2 '09 rares and the taurus usually goes for about 1-2 '09 rares

is this fair?

thanksss

also this one thanksss

1; im having a hard time finding a worth for the growing strawberry dog vs the 12 store pet, so i might come back to this one later tonight if someone else doesnt answer you
2; could be overpay or slightly unfair on their side as the '13 store pets go for 3-4 '09 rares and malk pets can be worth a little more since the artist is discontinued. the vr malk cat is worth 2-4 '09 rares, depending on who youre trading and what they value it but i believe the others are the normal 3 month rule.

hi, all! it'd be so nice to have a little help with this trade, please! <3

i believe this looks fair, i cant find a worth for the pps, but everything else seems to add up. the sunjewel is worth about 3-4 nons, joker is worth 1-1.5, BE Galaxy is worth 1 non, and the 12 store pet is worth 1 non as well. as long as the pps isnt worth an insane amount more (which i cant imagine) thats a fair trade c:

[spirited away]

fair?

[Flicka]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=89621881&userid=9355&signature=G_5KPpJRBcEzZrjbZt3X1A

If it helps, the Shampoo is from 2011 and the Rug from the same set. I would think its fair, seeing as both items are from 2011 and the pet is from 2009, and also is a VR ^-^
Please get a second opinion, there could be demand I dont know about!

Any demand we don't know about guys? I'm outta the loop more these days

[aniuk]

-snip-

hi, all! it'd be so nice to have a little help with this trade, please! <3

i believe this looks fair, i cant find a worth for the pps, but everything else seems to add up. the sunjewel is worth about 3-4 nons, joker is worth 1-1.5, BE Galaxy is worth 1 non, and the 12 store pet is worth 1 non as well. as long as the pps isnt worth an insane amount more (which i cant imagine) thats a fair trade c:

do you have any sources stating the '12 store pet is worth 1 non? I have never, ever, heard of them going for a non. everything i find says they're worth 1 midadvent, or 7-8 '09 rares. am i missing something here?

[wlw]

-snip-

hi, all! it'd be so nice to have a little help with this trade, please! <3

i believe this looks fair, i cant find a worth for the pps, but everything else seems to add up. the sunjewel is worth about 3-4 nons, joker is worth 1-1.5, BE Galaxy is worth 1 non, and the 12 store pet is worth 1 non as well. as long as the pps isnt worth an insane amount more (which i cant imagine) thats a fair trade c:

do you have any sources stating the '12 store pet is worth 1 non? I have never, ever, heard of them going for a non. everything i find says they're worth 1 midadvent, or 7-8 '09 rares. am i missing something here?

agree with aniuk, the fairy goats are definitely not 1 non

[gigi2526]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89780921&userid=900297&signature=27Awpon0Q5YrmzjMN0fP8A

I’m confused with what do do

[aniuk]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89780921&userid=900297&signature=27Awpon0Q5YrmzjMN0fP8A

I’m confused with what do do

basing this off of the 'how much is this pet worth in c$' guide,

A 2013 rare/very rare is worth around 12-15C$
A 2014 rare/very rare is worth around 10-12C$

they're offering an early-ish '14 + 2C$ for your mid '13.
going off of c$ values, your '13 is worth 12 c$ at the least, and theirs is worth 10 C$. they've added 2 C$ to close the gap. personally, i think it is fair going off of these values.

dogs have more demand than bunnies to some users, but the preference is up to you! i think the bunny is cute.

[Skarrred]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89780921&userid=900297&signature=27Awpon0Q5YrmzjMN0fP8A

I’m confused with what do do

basing this off of the 'how much is this pet worth in c$' guide,

A 2013 rare/very rare is worth around 12-15C$
A 2014 rare/very rare is worth around 10-12C$

they're offering an early-ish '14 + 2C$ for your mid '13.
going off of c$ values, your '13 is worth 12 c$ at the least, and theirs is worth 10 C$. they've added 2 C$ to close the gap. personally, i think it is fair going off of these values.

dogs have more demand than bunnies to some users, but the preference is up to you! i think the bunny is cute.

I do agree with this, but I personally wouldn't accept because of this lack of species demand <3