The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[mdsnlei]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89719435&userid=127913&signature=bPhl4n0qw9TyQx6ILYbyqA

Anyone with item knowledge know if this is fair?

[Skarrred]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89723206&userid=994914&signature=hu_OB9JCHx0aurw97ALZAw
Is this fair? thanks in advance!

[spirited away]

1
2
3
please help not sure rarities

[pg53294]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89665754&userid=696545&signature=JpDiggmnq-NEOhrxdmy5Cw Is this fair?

Still need some help with this

[aniuk]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89723206&userid=994914&signature=hu_OB9JCHx0aurw97ALZAw
Is this fair? thanks in advance!

no, you're overpaying. the 2014 common on your side is worth more than everything they are offering, as older pets have more value.

[~ moth ~]

hi! i have two trades i'm inquiring about! any help would be appreciated ^-^
one - two

[Pipsquawk]

This? im not good with bulk trades like this

[Skarrred]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89723206&userid=994914&signature=hu_OB9JCHx0aurw97ALZAw
Is this fair? thanks in advance!

Second opinion..?

[Yibeullin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89723206&userid=994914&signature=hu_OB9JCHx0aurw97ALZAw
Is this fair? thanks in advance!

Second opinion..?

i agree with above, you're over!

[beldam.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89723206&userid=994914&signature=hu_OB9JCHx0aurw97ALZAw
Is this fair? thanks in advance!

no, you're overpaying. the 2014 common on your side is worth more than everything they are offering, as older pets have more value.

since you wanted a second opinion, OP, i'm echoing this. the rarity labels may be equal on both sides, but the dates aren't - nothing about the pets being offered to you suggests equal worth to a 2014 pet, even if it is only a common

hi! i have two trades i'm inquiring about! any help would be appreciated ^-^
one - two

trade one:
this person is offering you a 2012 uncommon and a new pet of unknown rarity, when what they want in return i believe is roughly equivalent to:
one 2013 common (the four 2015 commons = two 2014 = one 2013), a 2017 uncommon, a new unknown rarity, and i don't think the 2016 pets can be broken down further.
unfair to them.

trade two:
they're offering a 2012 uncommon - now, i'm a little less sure on the math for this one, so someone please jump in if i've messed up, but i believe it's something like this:
four 2017 commons equal the worth of two 2016 commons, making for a total worth of five 2016 commons. if you break this down further, it becomes a worth of two 2015 commons (and a now-lone 2016), and from there, a 2014 common, plus the additional 2019 common. 2014 + 2016 + 2019 common can't break down further, and is not equal to a 2012 uncommon.

if instead they're possibly doing math by only rarity, treating 3-4 commons as a single uncommon, then they're still only looking for a 2016 and 2017 uncommon, with an extra 2019 common.
either way, i'd say this is unfair to them.