The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Zelfie]

someone help out with this please? 💕

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89694147&userid=921063&signature=zK5jTnvPbwYZp5FZ25WD8g

I know the 2011 pet on theirside does have demand but both of your pets are 2011 store pets to make it fair they could add something small

any second opinions? <3

edit: nvm got auto cancelled lol

[♡Raven114♡]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89694154&userid=991127&signature=HUMBzXkB1FaMfPRo_z-YSg

please help!!!

[doliork]

I'm auctioning off 105 pages of items, and I'm debating between these two bids. Could someone please help me and tell me which is worth more? One has a lot of older rares, but the other has some store pets and I'm not sure how that balances out.

Bid 1 - 32 pets total - 1 2009 VR, 1 2009 R, 14 2010 R, 14 2011 R, 2 2012 R
Bid 2 - 17 pets total - 2 2009 R, 3 2010 R, 3 2011 R, 1 2014 R, 1 2016 R, 3 2020 R, 1 2018 store pet, 3 2020 store pets

Thanks!

From what I know, The bottom one is better. Very little people like Rats so their demand isn't good, so I suggest you do with the second bid

Could I get a second opinion?

[Wings.mov]

I'm auctioning off 105 pages of items, and I'm debating between these two bids. Could someone please help me and tell me which is worth more? One has a lot of older rares, but the other has some store pets and I'm not sure how that balances out.

Bid 1 - 32 pets total - 1 2009 VR, 1 2009 R, 14 2010 R, 14 2011 R, 2 2012 R
Bid 2 - 17 pets total - 2 2009 R, 3 2010 R, 3 2011 R, 1 2014 R, 1 2016 R, 3 2020 R, 1 2018 store pet, 3 2020 store pets

Thanks!

From what I know, The bottom one is better. Very little people like Rats so their demand isn't good, so I suggest you do with the second bid

Could I get a second opinion?

I personally think the first offer is the best. Though rats do have poor demand, it's almost twice as many pets as the second offer and all have better value. Nothing in the second trade has high demand either, so I think the numerically better trade is more valuable.

[Tavros]

what would have to be added to this to make it fair?

edit: also how about this trade too?

[jokerslop]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89696359&userid=647223&signature=pdhFCeKfaEIYxSmtK5rGAg

im awful at trading so i need some help ,,

[Yibeullin]

hello everyone! i was wondering what i'd have to add to make this a fair trade? Valuing the BEG at 1.5 nons. And if someone could tell me how much c$ could be added to make this fair that'd be helpful too, but i'm fine with just pet value.

hopefully the link should work for y'all now?♡

[musicgurl333]

I'm auctioning off 105 pages of items, and I'm debating between these two bids. Could someone please help me and tell me which is worth more? One has a lot of older rares, but the other has some store pets and I'm not sure how that balances out.

Bid 1 - 32 pets total - 1 2009 VR, 1 2009 R, 14 2010 R, 14 2011 R, 2 2012 R
Bid 2 - 17 pets total - 2 2009 R, 3 2010 R, 3 2011 R, 1 2014 R, 1 2016 R, 3 2020 R, 1 2018 store pet, 3 2020 store pets

Thanks!

From what I know, The bottom one is better. Very little people like Rats so their demand isn't good, so I suggest you do with the second bid

Could I get a second opinion?

It depends on what you’re looking for. If you’re keeping the rats, then I’d go with the first trade. It’s offering quite a bit more than the second, which more than makes up for the lower demand of the rats. But if you’re not keeping the rats, then I might go with the second trade. Rats are quite tough to trade off fairly, although it can be done.

[CreamyFloof]

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89696511&userid=868350&signature=RwOPrWoUe_mOODKwGJ5YOw

[musicgurl333]

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89696511&userid=868350&signature=RwOPrWoUe_mOODKwGJ5YOw

It depends on how you value the store pet. Valuing a current store pet as a late ‘10 rare, they’re overpaying. Though personally I value store pets higher than the “official” values.