The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[lavender.haze]

Thank you, FriedApplePie and doubloon!

[MidnightDuchess]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88566019&userid=788138&signature=MelSqSgORVn4m192n90SXw

Should I accept this bid for my auction? Are the toxics that hard to trade off?

Honestly I’d consider the toxic extreme overpay. They must be valuing the set at a sorbet, which is how much the blue toxic is worth. I’d only value the zodiac set at around 3.5 MA’s or a low main, with each one being worth roughly 2 ‘09 rares. That would only be roughly .25 nons in total. Second opinions welcome tho, because they could be trading differently.

I would tell them that they are overpaying, personally. A sorbet for the set in pets is ridiculous

0.0 welp that’s good to know (was by bid) I’ll send a new bid instead that’s more fair with a pet that I know they value 3.5 MAs cuz they offered me 3.5 MAs for it already. I didn’t realize I was overpaying so much with toxic. Thank you.

[DisneyLuv]

Is this a fair trade? Thanks!

Definitely not, that rare spider itself is probably worth most of their pets on their side

Yes after doing some of the math, your side adds up to 2 ‘09 rares and an ‘11 rare. Their side only adds up to a ‘16 rare, a ‘17 rare, and a ‘19 rare. Definitely unfair to you.

[Lavendertoastmoth]

Older trade but.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=88123292&userid=988147&signature=_2DO8juLMHuvtBYKgWnIug
What do you guys think? Fair or unfair? I'm really bad with demand so I don't know if it was or not--

[DisneyLuv]

Hiya! Had an auction for the green liontail recently and was wondering which of these you'd recommend taking, if any:
BEG, Blue Sorb, WWA, Gearback, Assorted Rares
Noncoon, Nontag, C$250
Lolita + Ur Foal
Joker Bun, Purple Toxic, Patchy September, Assorted Advents + Rares
Thanks for your time!

This depends on whether you value the green liontail at 2 or 2.5 nons. The majority of these offers value it at 2 nons. The first one is valued at 2.5 nons plus a mid advent with the spiders. I’d say that’s the highest offer of the 4. The second trade is worth 2 nons with a small C$ add, and the 3rd one is worth exactly 2 nons. The 4th one, after my count if it was correct, is also 2 nons plus a mid advent. I’d personally take the first one, just because you’re getting its highest value. But they are all fair.

[kinderspirit]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88827612&userid=541778&signature=I8AVY1BrFi4Po6q-FP7JDQ
is this fair?

[Shrimplybad]

Hiya! Had an auction for the green liontail recently and was wondering which of these you'd recommend taking, if any:
BEG, Blue Sorb, WWA, Gearback, Assorted Rares
Noncoon, Nontag, C$250
Lolita + Ur Foal
Joker Bun, Purple Toxic, Patchy September, Assorted Advents + Rares
Thanks for your time! :)

This depends on whether you value the green liontail at 2 or 2.5 nons. The majority of these offers value it at 2 nons. The first one is valued at 2.5 nons plus a mid advent with the spiders. I’d say that’s the highest offer of the 4. The second trade is worth 2 nons with a small C$ add, and the 3rd one is worth exactly 2 nons. The 4th one, after my count if it was correct, is also 2 nons plus a mid advent. I’d personally take the first one, just because you’re getting its highest value. But they are all fair.

Thank you! :)

[jointedwishes]

would this be an acceptable bid for my auction? I havent been on this thread for a while, kinda feels good to be back :')

[DisneyLuv]

would this be an acceptable bid for my auction? I havent been on this thread for a while, kinda feels good to be back :')

This wouldn’t be fair to you. Your pet is worth 2 ‘09 rares, and they only have a 2010 rare, a 2013 rare, and a 2018 rare’s worth. They’d have to add 2 ‘09 rare’s worth.

[kadybeth123]

is this be fair? rare trades scare me ;-;