The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[DisneyLuv]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88566019&userid=788138&signature=MelSqSgORVn4m192n90SXw

Should I accept this bid for my auction? Are the toxics that hard to trade off?

Honestly I’d consider the toxic extreme overpay. They must be valuing the set at a sorbet, which is how much the blue toxic is worth. I’d only value the zodiac set at around 3.5 MA’s or a low main, with each one being worth roughly 2 ‘09 rares. That would only be roughly .25 nons in total. Second opinions welcome tho, because they could be trading differently.

[phxyvi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88566019&userid=788138&signature=MelSqSgORVn4m192n90SXw

Should I accept this bid for my auction? Are the toxics that hard to trade off?

Honestly I’d consider the toxic extreme overpay. They must be valuing the set at a sorbet, which is how much the blue toxic is worth. I’d only value the zodiac set at around 3.5 MA’s or a low main, with each one being worth roughly 2 ‘09 rares. That would only be roughly .25 nons in total. Second opinions welcome tho, because they could be trading differently.

I would tell them that they are overpaying, personally. A sorbet for the set in pets is ridiculous

[Moth Man]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88873080&userid=979673&signature=qI-u9j2nO-o9HChOUFyWGA
is this a fair trade? thanks!

[Pumpkin~Spice]

Could i get some help with this item trade? Is this fair? If not, what needs to be added?
Click

Any help is appreciated.

[DisneyLuv]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88873080&userid=979673&signature=qI-u9j2nO-o9HChOUFyWGA
is this a fair trade? thanks!

I’d deem this fair. The 2 2016 Store pets are worth an ‘09 rare each, and the malk cat fetched 2 ‘09 rares as well.

[lavender.haze]

Is this a fair trade? Thanks!

[Moth Man]

Is this a fair trade? Thanks!

Definitely not, that rare spider itself is probably worth most of their pets on their side

[FriedApplePie]

Is this a fair trade? Thanks!

It’s a lot of overpay from your side.
Just with your 2011 rare spider alone, using the 2:1 ratio anyhow, it could cover their pets. I would not personally accept this trade.

[kinderspirit]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88827612&userid=541778&signature=I8AVY1BrFi4Po6q-FP7JDQ
is this fair?

[Shrimplybad]

Hiya! Had an auction for the green liontail recently and was wondering which of these you'd recommend taking, if any:
BEG, Blue Sorb, WWA, Gearback, Assorted Rares
Noncoon, Nontag, C$250
Lolita + Ur Foal
Joker Bun, Purple Toxic, Patchy September, Assorted Advents + Rares
Thanks for your time! :)