The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Dollteeths]

Trade

Does anyone know if this is fair
thank you in advance.

[EmotionalBagageClaim]

Need some help

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88346399&userid=924074&signature=gcg6uvfzRJdcCj4-1nTFsg

Is this fair? I’m bad with demand and value, so any help would be appreciated

[Kabuski]

1
2

Both are red rose trades !
Idk what the demand is like for the rat, im sure it's not very good, but what is it worth.
Also, red toxics?

[symphonycraze]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88344041&userid=990393&signature=obhjJYW82Voe84YiL_PQiA

[Kuundzix]

This is fair?
Thank you for any advice

[Musicality]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88345387&userid=788138&signature=IkAnjQr_4adGcfMKq9MGKA

Is this fair for my full 09 staff set

[wlw]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88344041&userid=990393&signature=obhjJYW82Voe84YiL_PQiA

please decline this, your pet can get 4 '09 rares, sometimes even more, while their pet usually only gets 2.

edit: i see now its part of an auction but yeah this is not a good bid

[sunfloweer]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88338602&userid=956725&signature=aXECiO_LpFpNgFOLNIqZHQ

is this fair? what is the cheshire worth? do you know any successful trades for it?
- sunfloweer ^^

also this

the first link wasnt working so here it is again trades/viewtrade.php?id=88338602&userid=956725&signature=aXECiO_LpFpNgFOLNIqZHQ

been asking a while now any help is super appreciated!

[Catheren]

Trade

Does anyone know if this is fair
thank you in advance.

Dragon PPS Cat has what I call an "Extortionate amount" of demand, so even though I'd greatly consider that overpay the other player might still consider it underpay even though the kitten isn't really that rare.

For my personal advice: consider how much do you actually like the pet and whether or not you feel like you like it that much. Never do a trade you aren't happy with.

*I'll be editing this post to answer more questions sorry if some get double posted. I see you down there Sunflower, Imma get to ya quick! XD

also this

the first link wasnt working so here it is again trades/viewtrade.php?id=88338602&userid=956725&signature=aXECiO_LpFpNgFOLNIqZHQ

*addressing them from the one on top first and the bottom second, not in original order of posting- sorry for any confusion

The Chesire cat is another one of those tricky pets with "extortionate" demand, I would honestly personally consider the first trade overpay. Even if the Chesire is more rare than the others of the same set, because it only came as part of the "buy all" set, I don't think it's worth more than 1 or 2 more 09 rares than a jabbawok (for example), largely because it's what people wanted to buy most. I think the rest of the set made it made it to 3 or 4 09 rares from being a 2012 store pet (I put them at the lower end myself, but I'm just not a fan of the set) which could put it at 5-6 09s and that has the value just over 13 in pets alone. I think the other side of the trade hits a total of 16 with the C$ and firework, but I'd have to double check the item and I wanna move this along here

TLDR: I consider it a lot of overpay for a Chesire, but demand is between you and and your partner, so :

The second trade is a bit more tricky. I see two 2010s, but they're both Zodiacs and those guys also have some pretty reliable demand and I don't know where it falls presently- last I was trying to swap people put them at 2 09 rares each, I wouldn't value them less than 1 09 since they're super early 2010 and so popular, but that is debatable and a bit more between you and your partner.

For the rest of the pets I find it easier to swap to C$ prices, getting between 2.2-2.5 09 rares in value, give or take (I ran both the lowest and the highest values provided from the pet C$ thread.) So that does put it at least in the ball park, but depends a bit on how you and your partner value Zodiac pups and the Chesire.

TLDR: I consider this pretty close, but again, demand is between you and your partner.

Again, I always suggest people consider if they're happy with the trade before accepting: It's okay to overpay if you really like a pet and it's okay to underpay if you're being as honest as possible and your trade partner is happy too. It's also okay to cancel a totally fair trade if you're just not feeling it. Again, just be honest and try to be nice! =3

Need some help

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88346399&userid=924074&signature=gcg6uvfzRJdcCj4-1nTFsg

Is this fair? I’m bad with demand and value, so any help would be appreciated

Whoo a lot of store pets today, I'll repeat, the Chesire is one of those pets with "extortionate" demand. It trades for a lot higher than is really fair by rairty value and I do not consider them to be worth that much more than the rest of the store litter myself.

I see an older 2012 store pet in there and that should be close in value, by C$ maybe 2-3 difference; it is hard to account the Chesire could only be bought by buying the whole set but I'd call it pretty much even. The second pet is an old VR, Purple Heart/Husky if I have it right. Now, the Rares List is discontinued so that's a tricky pet to peg, could be worth 2 09s by rarity or from 4-8 by demand, and that makes things weird. It could be considered a little bit of overpay or an awful lot depending on how they value the Husky.

TLDR: I think this is at least moderate overpay, but demand is between you and and your partner.

If you're happy with it, you're good! If you're not happy figure out why and go from there: just be honest, and don't try to be a jerk! =3

[gigi2526]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88347184&userid=900297&signature=TKgKEkKrzzz6_rSB6tMPqg

I like chicken dollars, and it seems like a good deal, I just need a second opinion because that’s just how I am, lol