The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[DarknessANDLight]

Is this fair demand wise? I know rarity wise it is but I just want to double check what the sitting cats are going for with demand. Thanks!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=88328278&userid=42960&signature=xBV2l6HTN0Ezr1_ygUIt9g

It is perfectly fair, I do find the 2 rares there offering quite common but that might be just me, it's really about whether you prefer the sitting cat or the 2 rare dogs

[reynard]

would this be fair for my cheshire cat?

I think that the Cheshire Cat is worth more than this trade :?

The Cheshire cat is on the old advent list, so yes it is worth more than this trade.
Even if it was not, it is still an old store pet, making it so it is worth more than two '09 (if a 2013 store pet is worth about two '09 rares).
I do not think the 2010 rabbit they have is any special rabbit or has demand that I am aware of.

Because of the above, it is unfair to the Cheshire Cat!
and although I value the Verdana dogs super high because she is a sweet bean, I do not think that is how demand and trading works

[EchothroughDarkness]

Help, I don't work with items?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88328953&userid=410864&signature=DZDiXkVaEX4rFwST1z2AUQ

[gunthyr]

would this be fair for my cheshire cat?

I think that the Cheshire Cat is worth more than this trade :?

The Cheshire cat is on the old advent list, so yes it is worth more than this trade.
Even if it was not, it is still an old store pet, making it so it is worth more than two '09 (if a 2013 store pet is worth about two '09 rares).
I do not think the 2010 rabbit they have is any special rabbit or has demand that I am aware of.

Because of the above, it is unfair to the Cheshire Cat!
and although I value the Verdana dogs super high because she is a sweet bean, I do not think that is how demand and trading works

agreed, although i should add that the cheshire cat gets 2 mid advents, or 14-16 2009 rares, because of its demand.

[astraf]

is this good?

[EchothroughDarkness]

Help, I don't work with items?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88328953&userid=410864&signature=DZDiXkVaEX4rFwST1z2AUQ

[0ceanButterfly]

Hello! Any help with these trades would be greatly appreciated:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=88325589&userid=700927&signature=cVJdsH0B-gL6QUj76-MNGQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=88325611&userid=700927&signature=oqO5YiBSJT2Jn2S1l3WuVg
Thanks in advance!

[LilyHorse]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88329062&userid=985495&signature=dwvkuvUR7mYr1nPKDoQeUA

A lot of pets and items for the current store pets: fair?

[Figment15]

Hi All,

Thanks so much for offering this thread! I'm still new enough to have no idea of the value of items - is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88320382&userid=990204&signature=lT3OIW5MGsbwWNfqraZcbA

Can anyone offer any help with this one?

[EchothroughDarkness]

Hi All,

Thanks so much for offering this thread! I'm still new enough to have no idea of the value of items - is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88320382&userid=990204&signature=lT3OIW5MGsbwWNfqraZcbA

Can anyone offer any help with this one?

The item is a 2010 easter, so I think you should go with the pets. The egg might have demand with it being a old event token, but I still say the pets are better