The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Vaal Hazak]

]Its another trade??
They want me to edit, so what is the whole set of my store pets worth?
I have no clue, help.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88310988&userid=410864&signature=8CN35aBt0nVHix8QAxdjhQ

I've seen the Elemental Phoenix set going for a low mainlist, or 3 mid advents. Their side adds up to roughly 2.75 mid advents so they would have to add another '09 VR or 2 '09 rares.

[houndoom]

]Its another trade??
They want me to edit, so what is the whole set of my store pets worth?
I have no clue, help.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88310988&userid=410864&signature=8CN35aBt0nVHix8QAxdjhQ

I've seen the Elemental Phoenix set going for a low mainlist, or 3 mid advents. Their side adds up to roughly 2.75 mid advents so they would have to add another '09 VR or 2 '09 rares.

disagree. the rat is a September list. its super unfair to top

[AnnieDarlingxo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88318524&userid=321906&signature=uyHFA_6AynPZJBCN-_AkdA

Can someone please tell me if this is fair? I think it is but would like a second opinion just because its a high value trade.

[wlw]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88318524&userid=321906&signature=uyHFA_6AynPZJBCN-_AkdA

Can someone please tell me if this is fair? I think it is but would like a second opinion just because its a high value trade.

theyre overpaying imo. the horse and the vr rat swap, the spider and a '10 rat swap, their store pet is worth a '10 rare, and then their 2011 bwolf is overpay for your remaining 2015 rats. :)

[Nira.]

Hello, could anybody tell me their thoughts on fairness of this, please?
I'd appreciate a more detailed answer if possible c:
Thank you in advance ♡

[blood-moon]

Hello, could anybody tell me their thoughts on fairness of this, please?
I'd appreciate a more detailed answer if possible c:
Thank you in advance ♡

i am not that grate with trades but i do not think it is fair. they are offering you one omg so rare but want a older omg so rare from you. there are also asking for all the other pets when just the 2009 omg so rare should be more then enough

[snowdrake]

Hello, could anybody tell me their thoughts on fairness of this, please?
I'd appreciate a more detailed answer if possible c:
Thank you in advance ♡

i am not that grate with trades but i do not think it is fair. they are offering you one omg so rare but want a older omg so rare from you. there are also asking for all the other pets when just the 2009 omg so rare should be more then enough

please do not give advice if you don't know your rarities yet. the pets that are being offered are being valued far different than regular pets. please take a look at the retired rares list guide for more information.

that being said, I am sadly unfamiliar with the current value of both the ur tiger and liontail. I'm sorry I can't help.

[gunthyr]

Hello, could anybody tell me their thoughts on fairness of this, please?
I'd appreciate a more detailed answer if possible c:
Thank you in advance ♡

i am not that grate with trades but i do not think it is fair. they are offering you one omg so rare but want a older omg so rare from you. there are also asking for all the other pets when just the 2009 omg so rare should be more then enough

those pets have different valued not based on just rarity. please make sure you're certain before offering advice.
its unfair to them. the ur tiger is worth 6 nons.
valuing the liontail at 2-2.5 nons and the dogtag at 2, thats 4-4.5 nons on your side. i also counted roughly 11-12 mid advents by adding up all the other pets, so your side is worth 5-5.5 nons.

[EchothroughDarkness]

Is this bid for my phoenix store pets fair??
trades/viewtrade.php?id=88318478&userid=410864&signature=gyIhN7CH1TRn529X7m84Zw

[cαtαstrσphe]

Is this bid for my phoenix store pets fair??
trades/viewtrade.php?id=88318478&userid=410864&signature=gyIhN7CH1TRn529X7m84Zw

unfair to them, the blue rat is ex-September list and was omgsr so is worth sorbet+ and alone would be more than enough.