The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Mötley Crüe]

hi! could i get any help here?
is there any more demand for either of the pets than for the other or are they both just pets with no particular demand?

I’d say its fair!
Although, dogs/wolves usually have more demand than butterfly wolves.

It’s up to you which pet you like better tbh.

[greenfinch]

hi! could i get any help here?
is there any more demand for either of the pets than for the other or are they both just pets with no particular demand?

I’d say its fair!
Although, dogs/wolves usually have more demand than butterfly wolves.

It’s up to you which pet you like better tbh.

thank you!

[Caridina]

here
How can I adjust this to make it more fair/is it fair?

Wondering the same, that's me on the September side!

[MidnightDuchess]

here
How can I adjust this to make it more fair/is it fair?

Wondering the same, that's me on the September side!

Okay demand and values are all up to you guys since there isnt a list anymore.

Pink sept (mid septs) are typically seen swapping with with 2011 store pets = 1.5 MAs

1.5 MAs = 12-15 09 rares typically.

Store dog side is a tad under going by rarity not demand so demand probably would even it out especially as that 2012 VR is well sought after even though its just a regular 2012 VR. If its a trade you both are happy with then I think thats the best you both could hope for.

I personally think the trade is great for both sides but others may disagree with me as they have different demand values, as everyone values pets differently.

How does this trade look? I value my bun at a tier 7, not sure how to value the dog. Thanks for responses in advance!

By old list this would have been perfectly fair. (5ish 09s + 1 09 for 6ish 09 bunny) however people value list pets differently now so its unsure if they would have been valued the exact same as there arent many recent trades for the peppermint eared dog that I am seeing but I do know the bunny gets 7+ 09 rares now.

[frye]

is this fair? I believe the blue toxic is valued at a sorbet but I'm not sure how many t7's that would be. Would they need to add more?

[MidnightDuchess]

is this fair? I believe the blue toxic is valued at a sorbet but I'm not sure how many t7's that would be. Would they need to add more?

1 sorbet = 6-7 MAs, you are correct a blue toxic is valued at 1 sorbet.

Their side is 3 MAs + 1 2014 store pet + store items that are less than 10C$.

They need to add at least 3 MAs to be fair. (Im having deja vu I feel like I commented on a trade just like this with a sorbet dog instead of blue toxic a few days ago)

1 MA = 7-10 09 rares or T5-T6 - T8-T9 on the old advent list or any 2012 store pet typically
MA = Mid Advent

[Cassthe_Cat]

Please PM me with answers: trades/viewtrade.php?id=88182587&mode=cancel#cancel

[MidnightDuchess]

Please PM me with answers: trades/viewtrade.php?id=88182587&mode=cancel#cancel

Cannot view, use link at bottom of trade that has a "copy link" to the right of it

[faelyn]

Hi! Just got a trade with a few list pets and would like to get some help with it. I'm not the most experienced when handling trades and would like to ensure that I don't slip up on anything. ^^ Any help is really appreciated! <33

(link)

[MidnightDuchess]

Hi! Just got a trade with a few list pets and would like to get some help with it. I'm not the most experienced when handling trades and would like to ensure that I don't slip up on anything. ^^ Any help is really appreciated! <33

(link)

Coontail 2 nons
RBM (rainbow mane) 1 non
OMGSR rats 0.5n (at 3 MAs each for a total of 6 MAs which is 1 sorb/0.5n value)

Your side is about 3.5n

Sunjewel based on these semi recent trades I found is 3-3.5 nons (trades go back to early may)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87780344&userid=968026&signature=ZP47NUGb4yjdSFNrEo4rEA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87837559&userid=828108&signature=5bFkJOGU1bjTKf9ly0fCvw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87339767&userid=845505&signature=dzHva2iANmiUe6Hap5ha3Q