The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[DisneyLuv]

How do these trades look?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88164709&userid=970881&signature=rFs4PgKDAvzh7sdcnFVz8Q

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88167044&userid=970881&signature=IheU7AvydeHs2-X1EsIijQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88169835&userid=970881&signature=cvYcSb8ekv2raTNjkgJFUg (pretty sure this is unfair but wanna make sure)

The July lioness can go for approximately 2 MA’s, or a low September list.

In the first trade, they’re offering to a Grinner. Grinners can go for 1-1.25 MA’s which would be underpay for what the demand of the lioness currently is.

The second trade is overpay. The Red X PPS is a low mainlist worth at least 3-4 MA’s. Whatever you choose to do regarding this trade is up to you, but I’d take it.

The third trade is underpay, as you predicted. Although the reindeer horses have some demand, it’s not enough combined with the malk dog to even reach 1 MA. Definitely decline that one.

[Cory]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88170106&userid=20221&signature=zOZ60yEsDmdSgw01Oo_bEg

Is this good trade demand wise ??

[Karcrab]

I'm aware these bids don't add up i just want to know how much and what would be needed to boost their side? sorry and thankk you

[Vaal Hazak]

I'm aware these bids don't add up i just want to know how much and what would be needed to boost their side? sorry and thankk you

A Non equals 10 - 12 mid advents nowadays, their side is offering roughly 6, so they would have to add at least four mid advents or a low main list to make it fair.

[Kossen]

i have no idea about rare trading so im hoping for some input on this one

they are overpaying by quite a bit. both of their '10 rares = a 2009 rare. Even just one of their rares would be overpay, to make it fair youd have to be trading two '11 rares or the equivelent of that for one their '10 rares

thanks!! id love to get another opinon on this

[Cory]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88170106&userid=20221&signature=zOZ60yEsDmdSgw01Oo_bEg

Is this good trade demand wise ??

[musicgurl333]

i have no idea about rare trading so im hoping for some input on this one

they are overpaying by quite a bit. both of their '10 rares = a 2009 rare. Even just one of their rares would be overpay, to make it fair youd have to be trading two '11 rares or the equivelent of that for one their '10 rares

thanks!! id love to get another opinon on this

Definitely agree. The horse has no special demand that I’m aware of, and this is a TON of overpay. I’d personally accept this trade without a second thought.

[GL1TZY]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87783659&userid=978537&signature=z2hqLu5sOYz5lh20kzTpZw

A trade someone accepted a while ago and I'm wondering if it's fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88170194&userid=978537&signature=9zVLKF5S40IQvxuFblrJkg

Also what about this?

[snowdrake]

green sorbet = white arabian + clydesdale?

I'm generally unsure if the arabians are strictly valued at half a sorb? if they are actually valued at half a sorb will they likely stay that way or was it one of these one time trades?

[Camiracundus]

Is this fair? Bulk for a '09 VR?