The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sunfloweer]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88097408&userid=956725&signature=EpNAIQOIzM3OF6KZf046_g
is this fair? (considering demand too)

- sunfloweer ^^

[єℓσqυєи¢є]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88098207&userid=844777&signature=3LA7bpDWqFDftD6-UroQgQ

Hi! I'm a bit rusty with the (now expired) rareslist, so I have no idea how to tackle this one. Is it a fair trade, including demand and everything? Any kind of help is much appreciated <3

[Mally2678]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88098249&userid=938674&signature=QxR8ZhBvqDtFSvAivc1Aug ??

[phxyvi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88098207&userid=844777&signature=3LA7bpDWqFDftD6-UroQgQ

Hi! I'm a bit rusty with the (now expired) rareslist, so I have no idea how to tackle this one. Is it a fair trade, including demand and everything? Any kind of help is much appreciated <3

The fox is 1-1.5
The Aussie is 1 and their bulk is ~.25 if I were to be a bit generous. I think it is a great offer.

[єℓσqυєи¢є]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88098207&userid=844777&signature=3LA7bpDWqFDftD6-UroQgQ

Hi! I'm a bit rusty with the (now expired) rareslist, so I have no idea how to tackle this one. Is it a fair trade, including demand and everything? Any kind of help is much appreciated <3

The fox is 1-1.5
The Aussie is 1 and their bulk is ~.25 if I were to be a bit generous. I think it is a great offer.

great to hear! Could I get a second opinion?

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88098249&userid=938674&signature=QxR8ZhBvqDtFSvAivc1Aug ??

It depends on how you value recent store pets. Typically, they’re valued as a late ‘10 rare, so it’s unfair to them. Personally, I value them higher (I never trade mine for anything less than an ‘09 rare) because they’re never rereleased and their value keeps increasing. Given the low demand for ponies and rats, I personally think you could do better. But it’s more than fair, given the most often used values.

[Jacob]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88098207&userid=844777&signature=3LA7bpDWqFDftD6-UroQgQ

Hi! I'm a bit rusty with the (now expired) rareslist, so I have no idea how to tackle this one. Is it a fair trade, including demand and everything? Any kind of help is much appreciated <3

The fox is 1-1.5
The Aussie is 1 and their bulk is ~.25 if I were to be a bit generous. I think it is a great offer.

great to hear! Could I get a second opinion?

I agree with Bag's valuation. It's definitely a great offer for you!

[CoffeeEX]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88097528&userid=881679&signature=f_u74QL-VwD2fU1Fq4sYyw

Howdy! Is this fair? If not, what should I add on their side (They said I could edit, and I really want to get this to them since it's one of their dreamies!)

[phxyvi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88097528&userid=881679&signature=f_u74QL-VwD2fU1Fq4sYyw

Howdy! Is this fair? If not, what should I add on their side (They said I could edit, and I really want to get this to them since it's one of their dreamies!)

The mini husky, even with inflated demand, shouldn’t be above a t7
They’re offering a speck above that. Unless I’m missing something, they’re over

hi i would like an opinion on these trades for my ur tiger:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88098180&userid=675160&signature=9oRl_PL0hrRUhebbhWL9CQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88097564&userid=675160&signature=5M2otmJG45i5ptiMrPhSbg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88096324&userid=675160&signature=IV9-aQj85HhIrTvUNE_AEg

and another one

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88098462&userid=675160&signature=-cG2uUg3ZslYZ-yBYsbMbQ .

I think they’re all mediocre.


First trade

Clockwork=1-1.5

Mini dragons together=2-3

Spotted tribal=.5


C$=1

~4.5-6
You could get a more stable 6


Second trade/Fourth trade

The lts have settled closer to 2-2.5, i wouldn’t count on getting 3 from them

That makes their side 4-5 and yours 5-6

The third trade is promising, but eh

The eat me is 4-5 nons

I’ve owned about 2-3 now iirc and always had a hard time getting above 4 though that could entirely be bad luck on my part.

So their side is 5-6 and so is yours. But the tiger, notably, doesn’t have much of an issue fetching a solid 6

[Kookii]

hows this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=88098517&userid=992747&signature=to5rK07_ylhAXPT7aAvCdA