The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[mitts]

I keep offering this for the new store pets and every one is declining. Is it not fair? There's an '09 (the nick pet), two '10s, an '11, and a 2020 store pet. ;_; It would seem to me that I'm over offering, but what do I know, I guess?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89358884&userid=123271&signature=jnic7qan4yxOBzdv-Z7CdA

2020 store pets are worth a late '10 rare each. You're overpaying by 1 '09 rare and a bit here.

I want to trade my items for pets but this seems like a lot of items ofr just two pets? is this ok?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89148654&userid=969316&signature=O6Xe4IFS_nMzqRj_3T8zJA

Items are usually valued at an uncommon of their year. Even if both of the pets on their side turn out rare, this would be unfair to you.

[.Wolfskralle.]

Could someone give me their opinion about this trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89400926&userid=163939&signature=2t39ApDCeop0_6vSRNz2Cg
Thank you!

[Nestea]

Hi everyone, here a trade for uncommuns
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89410812&userid=1472&signature=z3f4zoIsbvoT1t95W5djtQ

is it fair, or 1 side should add some ?
thank you

[Shrimplybad]

I believe they're over? What would have to be removed to make it fair? Valuing the BEG at 1.5

[Khisyra]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89373684&userid=316356&signature=icjx7qtJO6raGYMO3cWJvw
Would this be fair? a tier 5 re-release for a tier 1 true date + 2 sitting 09 cats?

[Shrimplybad]

--accidental--

[MozarteanChaos]

is this trade fair? they're offering me exclusively pets on my wishlist, and a lot of them are pets that fit into my collections/hoards, but there's so many that i can't tell if their side is close to the worth of mine or not ;w;
i'm not bothered if it's not exactly fair, but knowing roughly how fair it is would be handy

[Darkest.Nation]

Pink sorbet for blue balloon? Thank you!

[DisneyLuv]

Pink sorbet for blue balloon? Thank you!

The pink sorbet goes for .75 nons and the blue balloon only goes for .25 nons. There’d have to be .5 more nons added to fill the gap.

[In The Darke]

TD Joker + 200C$ = Non-Jewelled Liontail

Valuing the Joker at 2 and the liontail at 2.5, is the C$ enough to cover the gap? I like this offer but I'm not sure the C$ is quite enough; if I'm right in thinking this could anyone give me an idea of how much C$ would be reasonable for the 0.5 nons difference?