The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Totomew]

this?

The Phoenix Set is worth 18 C$ in the shop, each item valuing at around 4.5 C$ individually.

Making the partial Phoenix Set a value of 13.5 C$ (although sometime item prices drop after leaving the shop I think it might be worth a small amount less), they want 6 C$ back along with a 2019 rare which I think is valued at around 3-6 C$, so it should be a fairly even trade overall with them maybe overpaying by a couple of C$.

[Black Clover]

should I accept this?

how's this as well?

[Kream]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87855819&userid=477181&signature=lFjySGTTXcSWT3Y4z69KGQ

Can I get some advice on this? They’re offering me 5 BEGs/CEGs + an OMGSR rat for a UR Tiger.

[Scary Blood]

should I accept this?

how's this as well?

First: Your Pet is Tier 7 while th other two are both Tier 1, correct me if i ´m wrong but i think that ´s an unfair trade, you might want to get another opinion

Second: Rarity wise your Partner is overpaying. If you care about demand, then Zebras usually have bad demand and it takes a lot of time to trade them away, at least for me and a few others i knew, so it ´s up to you if you care about demand or actual worth

[~mysticwolf~]

This is my bid in an auction, is it fair? ^-^
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87823252&userid=675816&signature=8IFyKkG0Wb7yh1mz36A95g
Wanted to see as I know the leopards have I believe bad demand

[Totomew]

The Phoenix Set is worth 18 C$ in the shop, each item valuing at around 4.5 C$ individually.

Making the partial Phoenix Set a value of 13.5 C$ (although sometime item prices drop after leaving the shop I think it might be worth a small amount less), they want 6 C$ back along with a 2019 rare which I think is valued at around 3-6 C$, so it should be a fairly even trade overall with them maybe overpaying by a couple of C$.

sure? I checked out in the year the phoenix set appeared in store items only category. It doesnt appear. Second opinions?

You can find the Phoenix set in the store under the "Extra Parts + Markings" category at the very end of the second page, that is what I was basing my answer on (you can find it in the archive under 2009 August the first page).

I hope you can find more advice!

[Riverivy]

is this a fair trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87859354&userid=816778&signature=bqECrGpiK8kdMrB5vX_bRA
please help me on this i have been gone from cs for a long time and have no idea about rarities and stuff.

[Jughead Jones]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87841667&userid=964187&signature=JV91Eih8mybkb2N3JMEMqQ
Fair?

Can someone please answer! I haven't gotten an answer in a couple days Thank you! I don't want to keep them waiting!

[Totomew]

Would a Winged Wood Angel(WWE) for a Orange Punk be a fair trade?

[Kassit]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87841484&userid=736471&signature=v1CmjR_sX-3Ji71ttr8_oQ

i honestly know nothing about re-releases, neither the pets offered