The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Yibeullin]

Would this be fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87849008&userid=976801&signature=SQFcYkM9Ferkei2VCU6v2A

That is unfair to the items.

Items are usually worth an uncommon of the year they were releases, unless 2010 or older then people usually trade for a rare of that year. Anyway, the pet is only a 2018 uncommon which does not nearly cover that entire trade. The only items I recognize at this moment are the silver arm wraps which are from 2019 summer event. Those other items are from a few years ago. Correct me if I'm wrong and feel free to get another opinion!

[Scary Blood]

Would this be fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87849008&userid=976801&signature=SQFcYkM9Ferkei2VCU6v2A

That is unfair to the items.

Items are usually worth an uncommon of the year they were releases, unless 2010 or older then people usually trade for a rare of that year. Anyway, the pet is only a 2018 uncommon which does not nearly cover that entire trade. The only items I recognize at this moment are the silver arm wraps which are from 2019 summer event. Those other items are from a few years ago. Correct me if I'm wrong and feel free to get another opinion!

Agree, unfair to the Items

[odin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87834319&userid=123271&signature=wL3Vefsz7Z1hhxd1-qZV2Q
Is this fair?

Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3915876#p121027946
Purple Toxic is worth 850C$

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87834319&userid=123271&signature=wL3Vefsz7Z1hhxd1-qZV2Q
Is this fair?

A purple Toxic is worth 850 C$
Though their demand isn´t that high i would still say unfair to you

Tank y'all.

[samiam52900]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87847800&userid=993343&signature=UfmOTn0oMG1WiupPU11kvQ is this fair, would you take it?

[Scary Blood]

this? trades/viewtrade.php?id=87849545&userid=987904&signature=h9nUAtiI-q7Xr5bUCj7bog

420 C$ is worth around a Rose PPS (Main List) so either a really low Main List or higher September List Pet, so unfair to you unless i missed a List Pet

[m a r c]

please help!!! is this a fair deal? i really want to accept (i would use the cerberus to get my missing store pets♡) but i want to make sure i'm not losing any profit

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87848991&userid=566332&signature=sbnbRRUbemrb5EtehQ9LBA

yes that's fair cerb is like 3-4 nons and your side is worth about that I believe

thank you! can i get a second opinion on the red cerb's worth? does it often trade for 4 or 3.5 more? I didnt think it went as low as 3.

[VashTheStampede]

please help!!! is this a fair deal? i really want to accept (i would use the cerberus to get my missing store pets♡) but i want to make sure i'm not losing any profit

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87848991&userid=566332&signature=sbnbRRUbemrb5EtehQ9LBA

yes that's fair cerb is like 3-4 nons and your side is worth about that I believe

thank you! can i get a second opinion on the red cerb's worth? does it often trade for 4 or 3.5 more? I didnt think it went as low as 3.

I've seen a lot of people going for 4 more than 3.5 as of late when it comes to just trades and not auctions

[KoiTea]

Would this be fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87849008&userid=976801&signature=SQFcYkM9Ferkei2VCU6v2A

That is unfair to the items.

Items are usually worth an uncommon of the year they were releases, unless 2010 or older then people usually trade for a rare of that year. Anyway, the pet is only a 2018 uncommon which does not nearly cover that entire trade. The only items I recognize at this moment are the silver arm wraps which are from 2019 summer event. Those other items are from a few years ago. Correct me if I'm wrong and feel free to get another opinion!

just one more agree, the the three bun wigs alone are worth nearly 8 times as much as the horse (I value a 2018 UC at 2 C$, and the bun wigs are sold for 5 C$ in the stores

[ketz]

this? trades/viewtrade.php?id=87849545&userid=987904&signature=h9nUAtiI-q7Xr5bUCj7bog

420 C$ is worth around a Rose PPS (Main List) so either a really low Main List or higher September List Pet, so unfair to you unless i missed a List Pet

this is true, but they're probably offering based on the individual value of each pet. there are 2 '08 VRs here and 4 '09 VRs. '08 vrs are worth roughly 60 c$ each, and '09 vrs are worth around 45-55 c$ each (though 55 is more on the end of high demand pets like sitting cats and lions and whatnot), so their side adds up to around 300 c$, maybe slightly more. you're still overpaying by quite a bit, but not nearly as much as it would be if they were trying to offer in terms of mainlist values.

[BlueCottonCandy]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87849698&userid=687800&signature=IV-8xj32Whbp5RR2FTgCaQ
is this fair?