The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Checkinder]

Thank you for all the help on my trades ;w;
How about this?

[Supreme]

Can anyone help me out with these bids I got for my old store pets? Which is the best, and is it fair?

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3

I need help ASAP, these trades have been sitting for a while

[xxhunterxx]

Which trade is better for my raven?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87759626&userid=964094&signature=jnDn98VGZssMbMjzMdGlmw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87783421&userid=964094&signature=o5KYNq6QZlnfhV81dMpT8w

I'm tempted to accept trade two because of the bulk but I'd like opinions!

While both are great offers, I would personally accept the second one. Lots of variety with good demand pets. I think it just depends on what your'e looking to get out of your raven.

Thank you! could I get a second opinion?

I would also go for the second one in my own opinion

[phxyvi]

Which trade is better for my raven?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87759626&userid=964094&signature=jnDn98VGZssMbMjzMdGlmw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87783421&userid=964094&signature=o5KYNq6QZlnfhV81dMpT8w

I'm tempted to accept trade two because of the bulk but I'd like opinions!

While both are great offers, I would personally accept the second one. Lots of variety with good demand pets. I think it just depends on what your'e looking to get out of your raven.

Thank you! could I get a second opinion?

The moonswirl is 2-2.5 and the raven is only 2 at max

The bulk I counted to about 16 ma + the purple tox
Which is around 2 nons, perhaps a bit over or under (depending on whether or not I counted correctly, and how you value the white feb and dragoncat)
Overall, though, I think you could get more for the moonswirl and it’s certainly a more stable/safe choice.
Not to mention the bulk is primarily in storepets from 2017-2020
These aren’t particularly desirable to most

Would this be fair?

Slep 2-2.5, and the basilisk set is .5

Your side is 2.5-3 and theirs is 3
Though if you added up the individual basilisks in c$ They would likely be under as they’d be around 900 c$ together (@300 each)

[VashTheStampede]

Hewwo. Could I get some feedback on this trade? I know they're overpaying, as most people seem to for the August PPS, but would you personally take this bid? I'm heavily considering auto'ing it, since I havent really seen it go for much more than this

What about this bid? Would you guys say this one is better than the above one?

[GL1TZY]

250c$ for malk element cat?

[phxyvi]

250c$ for malk element cat?

That’s enough c$ for a t7 for something that goes for a t1 at most
I would never pay that much for a malk elemental

[Checkinder]

Thank you for all the help on my trades ;w;
How about this?

Also this one?

[Mykie]

Is this fair? Whats the speckled rat worth? How many c$ can the rat go on its own? Thank you in advance!!

What can the basilisks go for?

bodeboop

[GL1TZY]

250c$ for malk element cat?

That’s enough c$ for a t7 for something that goes for a t1 at most
I would never pay that much for a malk elemental

Ok thanks for your help