The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Fizzlebee]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87784569&userid=963815&signature=ME_SdiXz0ZusggP7jOLaHA
I'm really torn with this trade because it's appealing to me; but then accepting will scupper my complete staff pet collection and I'll also be one dreamie down
What would you do?

Yes, your pets have crazy good demand, but the warriors and Zodiac also have great demand. Plus they're offering 1000 C$ on top of a generous offer. Considering it in terms of your collection, it comes down to the question of would the excess overpay be worth the time it takes you to trade for the staff dogs? The good news is those staff dogs really are just rares, even if they have great demand. There will always be ones floating around CS. It's just up to you how much you value the time it would take to trade for them to complete your collection again.

Personally I'd take it as I have a good amount of free time on my hands. c:

[Checkinder]

Would this be fair?

Edit: How about this?

first one definitely isnt, this might sound crazy but ive had those storepet deer before and ive gotten offers over 100 c$ wise for each, they have great demand. ive even seen them go for 150 before in others c$ shops. their trade is only valuing each at 56 c$*. from my experience trading with those deer and just seeing them sell i know they go for more. the other side could definitely add to make it fair.

as for the new trade im not sure. i think it just depends on how you value the staff pets, they could be more valuable to collectors but then again they are new and have low rarities so it really just depends on how you and your trading partner value them.

Could I have a second opinion, please? ;w;

[hellotheworld]

Hewwo. Could I get some feedback on this trade? I know they're overpaying, as most people seem to for the August PPS, but would you personally take this bid? I'm heavily considering auto'ing it, since I havent really seen it go for much more than this

The grinners have extremely bad demand, I honestly and personally wouldn't take it.

[VashTheStampede]

Hewwo. Could I get some feedback on this trade? I know they're overpaying, as most people seem to for the August PPS, but would you personally take this bid? I'm heavily considering auto'ing it, since I havent really seen it go for much more than this

The grinners have extremely bad demand, I honestly and personally wouldn't take it.

Grinner aside, what about the rest of their bid?

[lucky333123]

[/quote="hellotheworld"]

Hewwo. Could I get some feedback on this trade? I know they're overpaying, as most people seem to for the August PPS, but would you personally take this bid? I'm heavily considering auto'ing it, since I havent really seen it go for much more than this

The grinners have extremely bad demand, I honestly and personally wouldn't take it.

Grinner aside, what about the rest of their bid?[/quote]

The rest of the bid is pretty good and actually I would say grinners have okay demand.

[phxyvi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87784569&userid=963815&signature=ME_SdiXz0ZusggP7jOLaHA
I'm really torn with this trade because it's appealing to me; but then accepting will scupper my complete staff pet collection and I'll also be one dreamie down
What would you do?

its unfair on their half 1000 chicken dollars can get you a main list pet , i would take the trade

Please ask them whether they know their values? Their c$ alone is way more than necessary

[switchitup148]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87784609&userid=974515&signature=sK27fNjBrDXL4dnmoUlDyg
help?

I do believe this is quite unfair to you considering the high demand of warrior cats. I personally would not accept this trade.

[iago.]

Which trade is better for my raven?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87759626&userid=964094&signature=jnDn98VGZssMbMjzMdGlmw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87783421&userid=964094&signature=o5KYNq6QZlnfhV81dMpT8w

I'm tempted to accept trade two because of the bulk but I'd like opinions!

While both are great offers, I would personally accept the second one. Lots of variety with good demand pets. I think it just depends on what your'e looking to get out of your raven.

Thank you! could I get a second opinion?

[Checkinder]

Would this be fair?

[lucky333123]

Would this be fair?

Unless you want C$, I personally wouldn't do it. C$ is easier to find that those pets.