The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Lighinz]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724626&userid=701412&signature=7YLromKysn6uOfIPqEhicQ

Would really appreciate some help with this trade!

[Loelya]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724501&userid=854251&signature=iN150LDx5J-hjqN-TUszlg

I already got an answer that I was over by a good chunk of C$ (Like 70) and I was looking for another opinion before I cancel/edit ;w;
ty!

I totally meant to reply to you and then forgot oops - I read lio fotia's reply to you and I agree! the cat's demand doesn't seem to me to be more than about 80 C$ at maximum.

[OriginalStar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724501&userid=854251&signature=iN150LDx5J-hjqN-TUszlg

I already got an answer that I was over by a good chunk of C$ (Like 70) and I was looking for another opinion before I cancel/edit ;w;
ty!

I totally meant to reply to you and then forgot oops - I read lio fotia's reply to you and I agree! the cat's demand doesn't seem to me to be more than about 80 C$ at maximum.

Thank you! I always have a little trouble with lists and C$ ;w;

[s a g e]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724784&userid=576089&signature=i_7Bo0SnsKStj54PPYdgzA

is this fair ?

[ketz]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87720192&userid=670120&signature=ciwbR0wL7xm0TDcYkiwNBQ
not sure why this confuses me so much

pls help!!

rarity wise this is technically perfectly fair, both pets are off-list VRs from september 2008. however, horses have really bad demand, and tess horses seem to be even worse since theyre so hard to dress up or use for anything. sitting cats have excellent demand, especially actual warrior cats like yours is (blackstar), and can go for quite a bit more than what they're worth rarity wise. in '09 rares, the horse is worth 4 but would probably only go for 3 or less, while the cat is also worth 4, but could easily go for 6 or more. i'd say unfair to you.

[Loelya]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724784&userid=576089&signature=i_7Bo0SnsKStj54PPYdgzA

is this fair ?

no, the nonswirl (top side) is valued at 1 non and the dogtag (bottom side) is valued at 2 nons. they would need to add an additional non's worth to be fair.

[mothstrand]

Hello everyone, is there any chance I could get some advice on this trade?

Thanks so much in advance!!

[s a g e]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724784&userid=576089&signature=i_7Bo0SnsKStj54PPYdgzA

is this fair ?

no, the nonswirl (top side) is valued at 1 non and the dogtag (bottom side) is valued at 2 nons. they would need to add an additional non's worth to be fair.

Thank you c:
But considering the the non is a TD, how much are the TD nons going for ?

[executable]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724784&userid=576089&signature=i_7Bo0SnsKStj54PPYdgzA

is this fair ?

no, the nonswirl (top side) is valued at 1 non and the dogtag (bottom side) is valued at 2 nons. they would need to add an additional non's worth to be fair.

Thank you c:
But considering the the non is a TD, how much are the TD nons going for ?

Same amount as a non-TD.

[FOUND VERDICT]

^^
both are worth the same, but you won't find anyone trading an true date non for a rerelease...
they are rather hard to find and do trade for more in my experience, especially collectors are overpaying for them.

i paid an non + 09 ur dog for mine and there's also been another trade with an zebra + sorbet for one.
i'll search for the links if wanted.