The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Nari UwU]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5616823&userid=102242&signature=ZhHzFjeY__na0ATS5w9BPA

It's rare for rare, but I'm not sure if they're really equal. Thanks for your help! Would it be better to see if they'll accept the 2010 dog from January? They did ask for that earlier...

I say fair...or unfair to you, but get another opinion.

I say Fair too

[Caboose]

I'm really not sure if I should be posting this here or the how much is theis worth thread. ^^'
I can go to the other one if I have to. xD

Doesn anyone know what the best Auto for a Pink Balloon would be? c:
How about a Green Sorbet? c:

Blue sorbet and something else might be = to green... i think green is the rarest...

[Mazzie]

XD

Anybody?

[asexual]

are these trades fair?
1. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -OX7-8j4Sg
2. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 09kGdPk0jw
3. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mPMcHOM3GA

1:Unfair to them
2:I don't know, but my guess is unfair to them.
3:Unfair to you

Last two unfair to the bottom, top unfair to the first. Look honey, do not post if you do not know your rarities, which is plainly obvious. Others could get ripped off listening to bad advice.
Oh, and unfair to the UR cat ;3

~Atome

[Cellar x Elijah]

I'm really not sure if I should be posting this here or the how much is theis worth thread. ^^'
I can go to the other one if I have to. xD

Doesn anyone know what the best Auto for a Pink Balloon would be? c:
How about a Green Sorbet? c:

Blue sorbet and something else might be = to green... i think green is the rarest...

I should've stated that more clearly. xD
Besides other Sorbets[And yes Green is the rarest] what would be a good Auto for Green Sorbet? c:

[Mazzie]

I'm really not sure if I should be posting this here or the how much is theis worth thread. ^^'
I can go to the other one if I have to. xD

Doesn anyone know what the best Auto for a Pink Balloon would be? c:
How about a Green Sorbet? c:

Blue sorbet and something else might be = to green... i think green is the rarest...

Yes, green is rarest. It goes like this (highest to lowest)

Green sorbet
Blue sorbet
Pinksorbet=yellow sorbet

Atome@ Not true...let's ask Hekomi and/or jeweled.

[Animall]

Atome@ Not true...let's ask Hekomi and/or jeweled.

Atome is right, though O.o

[Hekomi]

That's very unfair to the UR cat. Peanut I really suggest you stop posting advice. You're going to lead people astray, they will get ripped off and it won't be good. You've been asked multiple times by multiple people to stop posting. The rares list alone does not give you sufficient information to answer questions.

Cellar; Pink Balloon auto would be a non-balloon. It's worth more but not too much.

[Mazzie]

XD

Anybody?

@Atome: Thanks!! Anymore opinions?

And this one XD

Hekomi:How unfair is it to UR cat?

[~BalloonBlu~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -yVjLam62A

Really not sure thanks!!! 030!