The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Shvlby]

Hello! Could I get some advice on this trade? How much would need to be added if this is unfair? Thanks in advance for any advice! <3

[kitkatsrthebest]

Hi, what is the Rose PPS going for (is it just a low main list or anything more specific?) and is the Purple Sleipnir still going for September and only occasionally a low main list? Not having much success in finding trades/opinions to back these values up when I search so would appreciate any help ^^

[♦sycakumaho♦]

person says this is over 2:1/4:1
lets see if its true!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87398822&userid=914375&signature=fFycVQz-4Yp0HaB9rvVRog

[kolechia]

I will admit out of all the offers I've gotten this is the most tempting but I feel like this might be unfair still? Opinions?

some help would be nice ;w;

[guy fieri]

How is this demand-wise? Thanks!

[scophinanaa]

How is this demand-wise? Thanks!

in my opinion you’re way over demand wise, only because i have seen the grinners go for over what they are really worth, just because people like the way they look! But, this has NOTHING to do with rarity, because i’m not too sure about that! hope this helps and maybe get a second opinion!

[KoiTea]

how is this for a trade with overpay? I'm unsure of its current demand, and requested overpay bc this pet is one of my favorites.

[Niragi]

not sure what you meant at all ^ but the horse side is very over because it can fetch a sorbet, while yours is very under. @guy fieri

I disagree. According to the discontinued list the purple tess horse was a low mainlist and worth approximately 465C$ while the sorbet is sitting at almost double the worth. I also, personally, haven’t seen any tremendous demand for it either.
Valuing the grinners at 1-2 ex-tier 7 dogs each, your side adds up to roughly 5-9 mid advents, whereas a low mainlist commonly fetches 3-4 nowadays from personal observation. I would say you are overpaying.

Even going by the rarity change archive the sorbets changed to the VR rarity in October 2009 and the purple tess horse in November/December 2009, therefore it can be assumed that it is still not worth as much as a sorbet purely based on rarity.

[Shvlby]

Hello! Could I get some advice on this trade? How much would need to be added if this is unfair? Thanks in advance for any advice! <3

[kkspecial4]

person says this is over 2:1/4:1
lets see if its true!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87398822&userid=914375&signature=fFycVQz-4Yp0HaB9rvVRog

Using the 2:1 Ratio -

1 2013 Rare = 2 2013 Uncommons = 1 2012 Uncommon
Using the 4:1 Ratio -

1 2013 Rare = 4 2013 Uncommons = 2 2012 Uncommons

Regardless of which ratio you use the top side is overpaying - rarity wise
Demand and pet preference is up to you to decide