The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[amarok.]

Hello! ♥
Are these trades fair / good for me? Thank you ♥
Trade 1
Trade 2
Trade 3
+ are all corgis worth the same?

For the bottom trade, the dog is from 2009 and i dont believe it was ever on a list, so it would be unfair to your vr 2008 card pup. and it depends on the person trading with you for corgis, but i've usually seen the rainbow and the merle fetch a bit more than the others

Actually the card dog is usually valued at 2.5-4 '09 rares and turned VR in 2019 so it's not particularly valuable whereas the valentines PPS was actually a low advent and valued at 3-4 '09 rares by most. It went VR at the same time as most of the t7 dogs (march 2011, eight years before the card dogs did) in fact, so is worth a *lot* more than the card dogs, and has excellent demand in its own right. I'd take it, personally.

[Sylvia]

Hey, could I get opinions?
Thank you!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86679581&userid=1464&signature=47PwAg5pIkzkrdabyFiKLw

[Luxio]

Hello! ♥
Are these trades fair / good for me? Thank you ♥
Trade 1
Trade 2
Trade 3
+ are all corgis worth the same?

For the bottom trade, the dog is from 2009 and i dont believe it was ever on a list, so it would be unfair to your vr 2008 card pup. and it depends on the person trading with you for corgis, but i've usually seen the rainbow and the merle fetch a bit more than the others

Actually the card dog is usually valued at 2.5-4 '09 rares and turned VR in 2019 so it's not particularly valuable whereas the valentines PPS was actually a low advent and valued at 3-4 '09 rares by most. It went VR at the same time as most of the t7 dogs (march 2011, eight years before the card dogs did) in fact, so is worth a *lot* more than the card dogs, and has excellent demand in its own right. I'd take it, personally.

^^ I edited my first post as i was aware i made a mistake after checking the valentines on the list

[ir0nh3art]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86662027&userid=302090&signature=aOYL-LufjK7gX9pHjTGO5Q

Is this fair?

[Luxio]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86673324&userid=672119&signature=yjGFEHWFKAAdWrreog8nwg
Boop, hows this? I'm liking those elemental cats and the dragon but im not sure about the rarity? Any help is appreciated, thanks!

Edit : And this trades/viewtrade.php?id=86679467&userid=672119&signature=q230ocbR9AeLl21iyP3nVQ I'm liking the dragona nd the owl is a dreamie, which would be more fair to take? Thanks!

[cαtαstrσphe]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86673324&userid=672119&signature=yjGFEHWFKAAdWrreog8nwg
Boop, hows this? I'm liking those elemental cats and the dragon but im not sure about the rarity? Any help is appreciated, thanks!

Edit : And this trades/viewtrade.php?id=86679467&userid=672119&signature=q230ocbR9AeLl21iyP3nVQ I'm liking the dragona nd the owl is a dreamie, which would be more fair to take? Thanks!

PPS dragon 100%, coontail is 1.5 nons and so is the dragon, maybe more or less since it varies, I'm not sure the other trade is even fair

[mae]

is this fair for my squid demand wise?

[Aremisu]

Thanks for the previous replies ♥

Hello! ♥
Are these trades fair / good for me? Thank you ♥
Trade 1
Trade 2
Trade 3

[kököchin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86673324&userid=672119&signature=yjGFEHWFKAAdWrreog8nwg
Boop, hows this? I'm liking those elemental cats and the dragon but im not sure about the rarity? Any help is appreciated, thanks!

Edit : And this trades/viewtrade.php?id=86679467&userid=672119&signature=q230ocbR9AeLl21iyP3nVQ I'm liking the dragona nd the owl is a dreamie, which would be more fair to take? Thanks!

PPS dragon 100%, coontail is 1.5 nons and so is the dragon, maybe more or less since it varies, I'm not sure the other trade is even fair

agreed c: the dragon fluctuates from 1-1.5 nons worth and the coontail fluctuates from 1.5-2 (more recently 1.5). i would say the pps dragon trade is a decent offer and if they're your dreamies, even more worthwhile <3

is this fair for my squid demand wise?

i wouldn't take it. as poor as the squid's demand, it is still far more favorable than the peas. the peas tend to go for a sorb, whereas the squid can go for up to a non ( :

[FireWolf52]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86662027&userid=302090&signature=aOYL-LufjK7gX9pHjTGO5Q

Is this fair?

I personally woulf say this is over trade on their part. The mint horse is actually "worth" about the same rarity wise as a ur tiger, but due to very low demand its only valued at about a non. Your dog is a non-tag, and in my opinion probably one of the harder nons to trade off (i had one myself awhile ago and it was a pain for me to get rid of), so the horse should be a fair swap for the dog alone. If you're concerned about low demand then maybe a small add on the horse's side, but not that much. Here's some links to trades i found with the horse valued at 1 non:

BMD (.5 non) + Blue sorb (.5 non) for UR Mint Horse
GWJ for UR Mint Horse
UR B-Wolf for UR Mint Horse + Bulk Stores (specifically said they valued the B-Wolf at 1.5 non)