"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[Panda-Love-100]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86333726&userid=940055&signature=KSgFTnMsFcZ7BvxYm9Qknw

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86276079&userid=940055&signature=ECwR_4v5lYI2hYl15Im23g

Is either of these fair? Tysm in advance!! <3

Both are very unfair to the rat!

Even though rats have pretty ad demand, if I'm not mistaken, this guy was on the list. Even if it wasn't it's still an OMGSR making it worth a lot more than you want/are offered.

WIth lots of patience, you could fine someone who collects rats or someone looking to complete their collection who will offer at least fairly.<3

Tysm Brekker! Would like to get another opinion just to be sure because someone has told me before that it usually goes for around 350 C$.

[-Isabella-]

I'm wondering if this is even close to fair? Or what might be fair out of what they are offering for my pet?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86342668&userid=587923&signature=DETZf_7zovnZ3D44Og2yEQ

[kanri;]

Is this trade fair?
I'm a newbie so, I'm still confused with these kinds of trades.
Any help is appreciated!

I don't think it's super unfair, but I wouldn't go for it. Their uncommons are all 2011+. I would hold on to that 2010 rare until you get at least a same year offer, if I were you.

[kököchin]

Thanks! How about this in place?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86346153&userid=5552&signature=jHN4UhYYRap-o5dps8ARYw

the android itself goes for a sorb. many users have been valuing the pink sorbet higher than the others but after the rarity drop, i really don't see any reason to value the pink sorb any more than it is. the basilisk on your side is quite unnecessary imo.

[(^-^)]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86319793&userid=954562&signature=yJHx5yAPvD0yVc0E6ydzzA
this and this
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86322902&userid=954562&signature=rA988cA0ETnK3-m8zDULvw

for the purple toxic?

[idontcareusername]

Is this trade fair?
I'm a newbie so, I'm still confused with these kinds of trades.
Any help is appreciated!

I don't think it's super unfair, but I wouldn't go for it. Their uncommons are all 2011+. I would hold on to that 2010 rare until you get at least a same year offer, if I were you.

I actually see this as fair, if you use the 2:1 ratio. One 2011 uncommon then the 2012 uncommon and 2 2012 common equal another 2011 uncommon, which would be fair for the 2010 rare. Then the normal 2013 is fair to the 2013, and the others are overpay since the last pup is 2019.

This is my opinion, and everything is up to you, but I see this as a decent offer<3

[impenguin2]

Thanks! How about this in place?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86346153&userid=5552&signature=jHN4UhYYRap-o5dps8ARYw

the android itself goes for a sorb. many users have been valuing the pink sorbet higher than the others but after the rarity drop, i really don't see any reason to value the pink sorb any more than it is. the basilisk on your side is quite unnecessary imo.

So remove the basilisk?

[kanri;]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86319793&userid=954562&signature=yJHx5yAPvD0yVc0E6ydzzA
this and this
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86322902&userid=954562&signature=rA988cA0ETnK3-m8zDULvw

for the purple toxic?

not sure about the first one because I'm bad with item trades, but the second one is definitely unfair to a purple toxic. The purple toxic is just below the big gap on the ex-main list. There aren't any ex-list pets offered in the trade and most of the rares are from 2018 or 2019. It would take a whole lot of '08 or '09 rares to even come close to fair

[Niragi]

Thanks! How about this in place?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86346153&userid=5552&signature=jHN4UhYYRap-o5dps8ARYw

the android itself goes for a sorb. many users have been valuing the pink sorbet higher than the others but after the rarity drop, i really don't see any reason to value the pink sorb any more than it is. the basilisk on your side is quite unnecessary imo.

Personally, I’d have to disagree. Even though the pink sorbet dropped back down to VR it can be said that it’s most likely rarer than the other sorbets as it was, in fact, omgsr just a bit ago, therefore it seems to be one of the pets right on the edge between vr — omgsr.
I’ve seen quite a few people generally value the pink sorbet at 0.75 nons now, right between sorbet to non value. Valuing the android at a sorbet and the basilisk at a high september to low mainlist, I’d personally consider this a fair trade. It’s up to you how to value demand though.

[(^-^)]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86319793&userid=954562&signature=yJHx5yAPvD0yVc0E6ydzzA
this and this
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86322902&userid=954562&signature=rA988cA0ETnK3-m8zDULvw

for the purple toxic?

not sure about the first one because I'm bad with item trades, but the second one is definitely unfair to a purple toxic. The purple toxic is just below the big gap on the ex-main list. There aren't any ex-list pets offered in the trade and most of the rares are from 2018 or 2019. It would take a whole lot of '08 or '09 rares to even come close to fair

ok thank you for the suggestion but i mean combined like both trades for the purple toxic