"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[atlos]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86208813&userid=709600&signature=1kaLXX90oGLHE0K2HOr_9g

Hi! Is this fair? What’s the Malk dragon go for?

[executable]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86208813&userid=709600&signature=1kaLXX90oGLHE0K2HOr_9g

Hi! Is this fair? What’s the Malk dragon go for?

Malk dragon goes for overpay, but usually not this much. Personally, I'd take it.

[Boneabii]

this trade? nwn

Unfair to you. The 09' VR covers for two of the Manticores, the two 10' rares cover for one, and the Manticore is worth a mid-early 09 rare so the other 10' rare needs another to be fair

[rosemary♥]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86207571&userid=623277&signature=T3qUU8yR5cjftBN7G7Wf5Q
Is this fair for my zebra? What are pineapples going for these days?

Any help is appreciated

Anyone know the worth of the ur pineapple

[insomnimaniacal]

is this fair?

i'm pretty clueless with big trades, any help is appreciated

[madisong]

is this fair?

i'm pretty clueless with big trades, any help is appreciated

definitely unfair to you.
Phoenix and Malk PPS would be fair swaps alone imo.
Their side would be valued between 3-3.5 as your side would be 3-3.5 as well depending on how you value the Phoenix.

[Free Shade]

Can I get some help on this one?

I'm not sure what the joker is going for atm nor am I sure of what their side adds up to.

Thank you for any help <3

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86210538&userid=459121&signature=8apc3MXblm-MDQFxhUMuiA

[phxyvi]

is this fair?

i'm pretty clueless with big trades, any help is appreciated

definitely unfair to you.
Phoenix and Malk PPS would be fair swaps alone imo.
Their side would be valued between 3-3.5 as your side would be 3-3.5 as well depending on how you value the Phoenix.

I would agree this is overpay but the Phoenix reallyyy doesn’t fetch 2 nons. It’s usually 1-1.5 although that is difficult as there simply aren’t enough trades on it to have anything conclusive

So without the bulk their side is 2-3.5

Whereas the zonkey side is 3-3.5

However you’ve got way more than needed on your side to close that range gap

[executable]

is this fair?

i'm pretty clueless with big trades, any help is appreciated

definitely unfair to you.
Phoenix and Malk PPS would be fair swaps alone imo.
Their side would be valued between 3-3.5 as your side would be 3-3.5 as well depending on how you value the Phoenix.

Wait, re you saying its fair or unfair? Looks extremely unfair to the bottom, since yes, the phoenix and dragon pps would be fair alone.

[Fierce Wings]

May I get an opinion or two on this offer please? I'm very much thinking of taking it. Thank you in advance! c: