"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[pluvio]

Hi! I am doing an auction and would like second opinions! I have already posted one bid on her and got an answer but I would also like another. Any and all opinions are welcome!
I am trying to get some sort of quantity rares as well!
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=85816957&userid=980494&signature=N5GKZN1isP4hFoo309wvEg

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=85817012&userid=980494&signature=OrGOv2Rv1PCGB8HJTlIB0A

3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=85817024&userid=980494&signature=j73LWJfFlHuohNtbjZb1IQ

2017 store pets = early '10 rare

First Trade = 1x late 2010 rare, 1x late 2011 rare, 1x early 2017 rare & 1x 2019 store pet
Second trade = 1x early 2009 rare
Third trade = 2x 2012 rares, 1x 2014 rare

The first two trades are overpay on their own. I haven't factored in the lower rarities/items, but if you're looking for quantity rares, I'd go for the first one because of the variety.

Get a second opinion just in case!

-snip-
I thought the main list matter and advent didnt matter anymore for it disbanded? Isnt that now a matter of demand and opinion/dates and rarity etc?

Players still use the rares list as a guideline but are aware that demand has shifted things off balance. Demand has gone crazy and as it's down to opinion, there has been an inflation in pet values. If you're looking for a new 'list' to go by, I suggest these:
- Guide to CS Rarities
- Recent High Demand Values

Thank you!

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85819463&userid=377988&signature=_nIHPsLgmalJvJrG6Cvwag
May I have some advice on this trade? I don't know much on the demands of the pets. Thank you very much~

The BE galaxy dog is on the mains list just before the big gap so it’s a big trade up from the clockwork bunny which is an advent list pet and the blue rose which is a tier 11 September list pet. that squid is also 2019’s special release pet and will most likely be a omgsr if that helps put it in perspective. As for demand, I’m not sure. Personally at this point - I’d just go for whichever pet you like best. Although you do have an opportunity to trade the BE galaxy or squid into something you like better that is currently worth more than your blue rose or clockwork bunny

Thank you~ May I get another opinion?

the list is very outdated and no longer applicable.

rarity wise, the BE galaxy is worth the same as a sorbet dog, which is above where many people speculate that the clockwork bunny now falls rarity-wise. the squid is impossible to place but it's worth betting that it'll top the blue rose, which didn't turn VR until December 2010.
demand wise, the BE galaxy trades for 1-1.5 nons (roundabouts where the bunny sits) and the squid is falling in general demand, so personally i do not think it will trade for much more than a non (if that) once its rarity tag finally appears. it's overpay on their side, almost certainly, but do bear in mind that demand for store pets is pretty uncontrolled at the moment and there's achance people will push the value of the bun up to a level where you might not be able to get one back.

[Andromeda123]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85414148&userid=819890&signature=wu0pAC3QBc6o5Lt3Rq77eQ

This?

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85414148&userid=819890&signature=wu0pAC3QBc6o5Lt3Rq77eQ

This?

that was extremely unfair to the other player if you go by the c$ guide, which outlines 1800c$ as roughly 5 non's worth.
even if you (incorrectly, imo) value 2000c$ as 2 nons, the avocado is mostly going for 1 non at the moment. 1050c$ alone would have been fair.

[EchothroughDarkness]

Is this trade fair??

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85811024&userid=410864&signature=QodTIR0SFcrq_OsjZPrbkg

And a bid for my new auction
Is it fair??
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85819855&userid=410864&signature=8SY-tBBqAZfhFRHWJEff-g

Another bid
Is this one fair??
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85819871&userid=410864&signature=hP5NZaLFo723AYAAl_HeXQ

And this one??
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85819998&userid=410864&signature=Gh2hl-MYl5Q6EaLhRIY2eQ

[Mya.]

I need some help with this trade; how much would I need to add to make this fair for the BEG
the BEG is worth 1-1.5 nons, so I need to know my side's worth and how much I need to add to make it fair for them
thank you in advance!
> Click <

[Thistlestar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85792060&userid=905071&signature=liBz-T_eP8b_uIozyvNsUg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85820061&userid=905071&signature=ERrEa68uCXgiaMCXtLwBUA

Help?

[ahirked]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85792060&userid=905071&signature=liBz-T_eP8b_uIozyvNsUg

Help?

Malk Elemental Cats = 2 '09 rares / 1 '09 VR with 3-month rule
Their dog is a VR rerelease from Jan '09, your cat is a rerelease from May '09, so they're overpaying.

Demand-wise, the cats have more demand, but more so the Air, Fire and Water elements than the Earth cat, but they can go for a little more because they're more sought-after than the dog.

[amarok.]

I need some help with this trade; how much would I need to add to make this fair for the BEG
the BEG is worth 1-1.5 nons, so I need to know my side's worth and how much I need to add to make it fair for them
thank you in advance!
> Click <

the BEG is actually only worth a sorbet, firstly. it just trades for 1-1.5 nons. that's an important distinction.
rarity wise, the red toxic alone is fair according to rarity change data/the three month rule, but demand wise it only trades for 0.75 sorbets and therefore you'd need to add at least another red toxic's worth, probably two. i can't speak for the items but i'm fairly certain they make very little difference to the trade overall.

[Rbpuppy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85414148&userid=819890&signature=wu0pAC3QBc6o5Lt3Rq77eQ

This?

Very unfair to them, the Avocado usually trades for about 1 non depending on the demand you place on it. Still unfair to them however.